Placodermi

Placodermi (from the Ancient Greek plax, "plate," and derma, "skin," literally "plate-skinned") is an extinct class or paraphyletic stem-grade of armored jawed vertebrates (Gnathostomata) that dominated marine and freshwater ecosystems from the Early Silurian (~435 million years ago) until their complete extinction at the end-Devonian Hangenberg Crisis (358.9 Ma). Accounting for the majority of vertebrate diversity during the Devonian Period ("The Age of Fishes"), placoderms ranged from 10-cm benthic detritus-feeders (Bothriolepis) and ray-like flat bottom-dwellers (Gemuendina) to 6- to 8-meter pelagic apex superpredators (Dunkleosteus terrelli)—the first vertebrate megapredators in Earth's history.

Placoderms occupy the pivotal evolutionary node at the origin of jaws, paired pelvic fins, true teeth, macromeric facial bones, and internal fertilization (viviparity) in the vertebrate tree of life:

1. Articulated Head and Thoracic Dermal Armor: The head and anterior trunk are encased in two interlocking shields of cellular dermal bone ornamented with semidentine tubercles, joined in derived forms by a mobile cranio-thoracic neck joint that allowed the skull roof to rock upward during jaw opening.
2. Self-Sharpening Gnathal Bone Plates and Early Teeth: Rather than continuously replaced shark-like tooth whorls, most placoderms armed their palatoquadrate and Meckel's cartilage with bony supragnathal and infragnathal plates that sheared against each other like self-sharpening guillotine blades (supplemented at the margins by authentic dentine-capped teeth added without resorption).
3. Pelvic Claspers and the Earliest Vertebrate Live Birth (Materpiscis): Exquisitely three-dimensionally preserved Late Devonian specimens from the Gogo Formation of Western Australia demonstrate that placoderms reproduced by internal fertilization using paired bony male pelvic claspers and gave birth to live young nourished via an umbilical cord and yolk-sac placenta.

Throughout the 20th century, Placodermi was regarded as a monophyletic sister class to all crown jawed vertebrates (Chondrichthyes + Osteichthyes), and the shark-like cartilaginous skull of Chondrichthyes was assumed to represent the primitive gnathostome condition (implying that bony fishes [Osteichthyes] evolved their dermal maxilla, premaxilla, and dentary bones de novo).

That textbook paradigm was overturned by two breakthroughs:

1. Phylogenetic Paraphyly of Placodermi (Brazeau, 2009; Davis et al., 2012): Cladistic analyses of braincase neurocrania demonstrate that "Placodermi" is a paraphyletic grade of sequential stem-gnathostome lineages leading step-by-step from jawless osteostracans to the last common ancestor of cartilaginous and bony fishes.
2. Discovery of the Silurian "Maxillate Placoderms" (Entelognathus and Qilinyu): In 2013 and 2016, Min Zhu, Per Ahlberg, and colleagues described Entelognathus primordialis and Qilinyu rostrata from the Late Silurian Kuanti Formation (~423 Ma) of Yunnan, China. These fishes possessed a classic placoderm dermal trunk shield and neurocranium, yet their jaws were framed externally by true osteichthyan-style marginal dermal jaw bones—a premaxilla, maxilla, and dentary—plus an opercular gill cover! This discovery proved that bony fishes (Osteichthyes) inherited their facial bones directly from derived placoderms, whereas sharks and rays (Chondrichthyes) secondarily lost their ancestral macromeric dermal skull and jaw armor.

Total-Group Gnathostomata (Jawed Vertebrates, Early Silurian ~438 Ma) ├── †Order Antiarchi (*Bothriolepis*, *Pterichthyodes*, *Microbrachius*; box-like armor, jointed arthropod-like pectoral appendages; ~435–359 Ma) └── Next-Step Stem Gnathostomes ├── †Order Petalichthyida (*Lunaspis*, *Macropetalichthys*) & †Order Rhenanida (*Gemuendina stuertzi*: skate-like flat body) ├── †Order Ptyctodontida (*Materpiscis attenboroughi*, *Campbellodus*: chimaera-like durophages with pelvic claspers & viviparity) ├── †Order Acanthothoraci (*Romundina stellina*: Early Devonian facial trabeculae & radial tooth-addition plates) ├── †Order Arthrodira ("Joint-Necks": >60% of all placoderm species; *Coccosteus*, *Eastmanosteus*, *Dunkleosteus*, *Titanichthys*) └── †"Maxillate Placoderms" (*Entelognathus primordialis*, *Qilinyu rostrata*; Late Silurian ~423 Ma: true premaxilla, maxilla, & dentary!) └── Crown Gnathostomata ├── Total-Group Chondrichthyes (†"Acanthodians" + Sharks, Rays, & Chimaeras; secondary loss of dermal bone armor) └── Total-Group Osteichthyes (Bony Fishes: Actinopterygii + Sarcopterygii [including Tetrapoda]) *`

The Late Devonian (Famennian, ~365–359 Ma) pelagic arthrodire Dunkleosteus terrelli (preserved in the Cleveland Shale of Ohio and contemporaneous strata in Morocco and Poland) grew to 5–8.8 meters in length and 1 to 4 tonnes in body mass. Biomechanical modeling by Philip Anderson and Mark Westneat (2007) demonstrated that Dunkleosteus achieved one of the fastest and most powerful bites in vertebrate history via a four-bar mechanical linkage connecting the skull roof, thoracic shield, lower jaw (inferognathal), and quadrate/cheek complex:

1. Simultaneous Cranial Elevation and Mandibular Depression: Unlike most vertebrates (which open the mouth solely by dropping the lower jaw), Dunkleosteus contracted massive epaxial muscles inserting on the back of the neurocranium to rotate the entire head shield upward by 15–20° around the paired ball-and-socket cranio-thoracic neck joints at the exact same instant that hypaxial (coracomandibular) muscles pulled the lower jaw downward.
2. 20-Millisecond Suction Expansion: This four-bar linkage opened the gape completely in just 20 milliseconds (1/50th of a second), generating powerful negative intra-oral pressure (suction feeding) that Vacuumed armored fish and ammonoids into the mouth.
3. 5,300-Newton Fang-Tip Stress and Self-Sharpening Guillotine Shear: Adductor mandibulae contraction drove the anterior pick-like fangs of the inferognathal upward with a bite force of 4,400 N at the fang tip and 5,300 N at the rear blade. Concentrated onto a tiny cross-sectional fang area, this generated contact pressures exceeding 100–150 MPa (22,000 psi)—sufficient to punch cleanly through dermal bone armor and slice prey in half along the self-sharpening bevel of the gnathal plates (with regurgitated boluses of semi-digested placoderm armor plates preserved as bromalites in the Cleveland Shale).
4. Filter-Feeding Giant Relative (Titanichthys): Contemporaneous with Dunkleosteus, its sister giant arthrodire Titanichthys (reaching 5–7 m) evolved narrow, toothless, rod-like lower jaws incapable of high-stress biting, pioneering pelagic suspension feeding (ram-feeding planktivory) 150 million years before pachycormid fishes, whale sharks, and baleen whales!

Acid-preparation and synchrotron X-ray microtomography of carbonate concretions from the Late Devonian (~380 Ma, Frasnian) Gogo Formation reef complex in Western Australia (Long et al., 2008, 2009, 2015) revealed that placoderms did not spawn externally like most modern teleost fishes; instead, internal fertilization and matrotrophic/lecithotrophic viviparity was the ancestral reproductive mode across Placodermi:

• Materpiscis attenboroughi ("Mother Fish"): A 28-cm female ptyctodontid fossil preserved with an unhatched intrauterine embryo containing partially ossified head armor and gnathal plates, still attached to its mother by a mineralized umbilical cord (containing an umbilical artery, vein, and vitelline duct connected to a vascularized yolk sac).
• Incisoscutum ritchiei and Austroptyctodus: Subsequent Gogo arthrodire fossils preserved twin embryos inside the maternal body cavity, accompanied in males by paired, articulated bony pelvic claspers situated independent of and posterior to the pelvic fins.
• Origin of Copulation in Microbrachius dicki: Even in the most basal placoderm order (Antiarchi), John Long and colleagues (2015) discovered that male Microbrachius dicki (a 8-cm freshwater antiarch from the Middle Devonian of Scotland and Estonia) possessed large, grooved L-shaped bony genital claspers, while females possessed paired dermal genital plates that locked the male's claspers in place as the pair copulated side-by-side (arm-in-arm using their jointed pectoral appendages).

After surviving the Frasnian–Famennian Kellwasser Events (372 Ma, which decimated tropical stromatoporoid–coral reefs and benthic antiarchs/ptyctodonts), the surviving pelagic arthrodires (Dunkleosteus, Titanichthys) and freshwater Bothriolepis were completely extinguished at the end-Devonian Hangenberg Crisis (358.9 Ma)—driven by widespread ocean anoxia (black shale deposition), volcanism, and sudden glaciation of Gondwana. Their extinction vacated every marine and freshwater apex predator and durophagous niche, triggering the rapid Early Carboniferous (Mississippian) radiation of crown chondrichthyans (sharks and holocephalans) and actinopterygian / sarcopterygian bony fishes (Tetrapoda).

1. Janvier, P. (1996). Early Vertebrates. Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
2. Anderson, P. S., & Westneat, M. W. (2007). Feeding mechanics and bite force modelling of the skull of Dunkleosteus terrelli, an ancient apex predator. Biology Letters, 3(1), 77–80. Google Scholar
3. Long, J. A., Trinajstic, K., Young, G. C., & Senden, T. (2008). Live birth in the Devonian period. Nature, 453(7195), 650–652. Google Scholar
4. Zhu, M., Yu, X., Ahlberg, P. E., Choo, B., Lu, J., Qiao, T., ... & Zhu, Y. A. (2013). A Silurian placoderm with osteichthyan-like marginal jaw bones. Nature, 502(7470), 188–193. Google Scholar

• Vertebrata
• Chordata
• Tetrapoda
• Ichthyosauria
• Mass Extinction