A large, dark-bodied deep-sea shark hauled up for decades in commercial shrimp trawls off India's southwestern coast has been formally recognized as a species new to science: the Indian bramble shark, Echinorhinus roinee.[1] Described by P. Rozario, K. K. Bineesh, S. Beura, K. V. Akhilesh, A. Kasinath, and D. Banerjee from the Zoological Survey of India (ZSI) and the ICAR-Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute (CMFRI) in Records of the Zoological Survey of India (Vol. 126, Issue 1S, 2026), the newly named elasmobranch—capable of reaching nearly 3 meters (10 feet) in length—had long been misidentified as the Atlantic bramble shark (Echinorhinus brucus).[1, 2]
The recognition of Echinorhinus roinee illustrates how cryptic biodiversity can persist inside well-documented fisheries bycatch, particularly across deep continental-slope ecosystems where limited sampling and superficial morphological similarity obscure evolutionary divergence.[1, 3]
Hiding in Plain Sight Along the Kerala Continental Slope
Bramble sharks belong to the family Echinorhinidae, a morphologically distinctive group of deep-water sharks characterized by stout, cylindrical bodies and scattered, thorn-like dermal denticles. Until now, Indian Ocean specimens were routinely assigned to the Atlantic bramble shark (Echinorhinus brucus).[1]
Off the coast of Kerala in southwestern India, deep-sea crustacean trawlers operating along the upper continental slope at depths between 350 and 450 meters periodically capture large bramble sharks as incidental bycatch, landing specimens at hubs such as the Sakthikulangara Fishing Harbour in Kollam.[1, 2] Because their dark brown-to-black coloration and thorny skin superficially resembled Atlantic specimens, regional fisheries records and museum catalogs routinely assigned them to Echinorhinus brucus without dedicated comparative or molecular testing.[1]
| Taxonomic / Ecological Trait | Echinorhinus roinee (Indian Bramble Shark) | Comparison to Echinorhinus brucus |
|---|---|---|
| Order / Family | Echinorhiniformes: Echinorhinidae | Same family; represents distinct Indian Ocean lineage |
| Type Region & Depth | Southwestern coast of India (Kerala), ~350–450 m | E. brucus originally characterized from Atlantic waters |
| Maximum Size | Up to ~3 meters (~10 feet) | Comparable large-bodied continental-slope predator |
| Diagnostic Morphology | Larger eyes, larger pelvic fins, longer snout-to-gill span | Proportional cranial and fin differences separate taxa |
| Skin Dentition | Thorn-like dermal denticles fusing into multi-pointed plates | Shared family trait, paired with distinct mitochondrial DNA |
Morphological Diagnostics and Mitochondrial DNA Barcoding
To test whether Indian Ocean bramble sharks truly belonged to the Atlantic species, the ZSI and CMFRI team applied integrative taxonomy—combining fine-scale morphometric measurements with mitochondrial DNA barcoding.[1, 2] Careful anatomical comparison of landed specimens revealed consistent, diagnostic proportional differences that separate Echinorhinus roinee from Echinorhinus brucus.[1, 3]
Specifically, Echinorhinus roinee exhibits measurably larger eyes—an adaptation consistent with low-light visual foraging along the mesopelagic and upper-bathyal slope—alongside proportionally larger pelvic fins and an elongated snout-to-gill region.[1, 4] Like its congeners, its dark brown-to-black epidermis is armored with large, thorn-like dermal denticles that frequently fuse into multi-pointed basal plates.[1, 3] Mitochondrial DNA sequencing independently confirmed deep genetic divergence from Atlantic E. brucus, establishing E. roinee as an evolutionarily distinct Indian Ocean lineage.[1, 2]
Deep-Sea Fisheries Bycatch and Conservation Implications
Separating a widespread, supposedly cosmopolitan deep-sea species into regionally restricted lineages has immediate consequences for marine conservation and fisheries management.[1, 3] Deep-water elasmobranchs—including bramble sharks, gulper sharks, and deep-sea skates—typically exhibit slow somatic growth, late sexual maturity, and low reproductive output, making populations highly vulnerable to sustained bottom-trawling pressure.
When a regional endemic such as Echinorhinus roinee is mistakenly lumped under a global species name like E. brucus, stock assessments can mask localized depletion behind apparent global abundance. Recognizing E. roinee as a distinct species restricted to Indian Ocean slope habitats off southwestern India enables fisheries agencies to track catch rates, monitor bycatch mortality in deep-sea shrimp fisheries, and evaluate extinction risk accurately at the regional level.[1, 4]
Cryptic Speciation in the Indian Ocean Bathyal Zone
The discovery also adds to a growing body of evidence that the northern Indian Ocean's continental slopes harbor previously unrecognized chondrichthyan diversity. Steep bathymetric gradients, seasonal oxygen-minimum zones along the Arabian Sea margin, and historical oceanographic barriers promote allopatric isolation among benthic and benthopelagic predators that rarely cross open abyssal plains.
By pairing museum-grade morphometrics with molecular barcoding on specimens recovered directly from commercial landings, the ZSI and CMFRI researchers demonstrated that even 3-meter apex and mesopredatory sharks can remain taxonomically hidden in plain sight—underscoring the value of routine genetic screening in deep-sea fisheries monitoring.[1, 2, 3]
References & Primary Sources
- [1] The Hindu (2026). New shark species identified in Indian Ocean after decades of misclassification (reporting on Rozario, P., Bineesh, K. K., Beura, S., Akhilesh, K. V., Kasinath, A., & Banerjee, D., Records of the Zoological Survey of India, 126(i1S), 41–58). — https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/science/new-shark-species-identified-in-indian-ocean-after-decades-of-misclassification/article71694050.ece
- [2] The Times of India (2026). A 3-metre shark caught off Kerala puzzled scientists for decades: DNA finally revealed its secret. — https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/education/news/a-3-metre-shark-caught-off-kerala-puzzled-scientists-for-decades-dna-finally-revealed-its-secret/articleshow/135755452.cms
- [3] ThePrint (2026). Meet India’s newest deep-sea shark, a 10-foot giant scientists had misidentified for decades. — https://theprint.in/theprint-essential/meet-indias-newest-deep-sea-shark-a-10-foot-giant-scientists-had-misidentified-for-decades/3099736/
- [4] Shankar IAS Parliament (2026). New shark species identified in Indian Ocean. — https://www.shankariasparliament.com/current-affairs/new-shark-species-identified-in-indian-ocean