Dish and Pillar Fluid-Escape Structures
Dish and pillar structures are early post-depositional water-escape structures formed in rapidly deposited, fluidized sand beds when upward-migrating pore water segregates fine clay laminae into concave-upward dishes and vertical fluidization chimneys.
Dish and Pillar Fluid-Escape Structures are diagnostic early post-depositional dewatering structures preserved in thick, rapidly accumulated sandstone beds deposited by high-density turbidity currents, fluidized sediment flows, and hyperpycnal river discharges. Within clastic sedimentology and geology, these structures record the expulsion of large volumes of interstitial pore water trapped when a concentrated sand-water suspension freezes or settles too rapidly for water to drain passively during deposition. First recognized in Paleogene deep-marine sandstones of the California Coast Ranges by Carl M. Wentworth in 1967 and mechanistically analyzed by Donald R. Lowe and Richard D. LoPiccolo in 1974, dish structures appear in vertical outcrop profiles as thin, dark, concave-upward clay- and organic-rich seams that give the sandstone a scaly or stacked-saucer fabric. Pillar structures are vertical to steeply inclined columns of massive, structureless, cleaner sand that pierce upward between and through the margins of the dishes, representing high-velocity fluidization chimneys. Together with basal flute casts and sole markings, intrastratal convolute lamination, and density-driven ball-and-pillow structures, dish and pillar fabrics serve as primary indicators of submarine canyon-fill, inner-fan channel, and proximal lobe deposits—particularly within the S3 and R3 divisions of Lowe high-density turbidites.
Morphology and Vertical Zoning Within Sandstone Beds
Dish and pillar structures occur most commonly in medium- to fine-grained, moderately sorted sandstones (d50 ≈ 0.12 to 0.50 mm) containing a small fraction (typically 1–5% by weight) of dispersed detrital clay, mica flakes, or fine carbonaceous debris, hosted within beds ranging from 0.4 to more than 5 m in thickness.
Anatomy of Dish Structures
An individual dish structure consists of a dark, clay- or silt-enriched basal lamina 0.2 to 3 mm thick that is concave-upward in vertical cross-section and circular, elliptical, or polygonal in horizontal plan view:
- Dimensions and Curvature: Individual dishes measure 2 to 50 cm in horizontal diameter (most commonly 5 to 25 cm) and 0.5 to 8 cm in vertical depth. Each dish is sharpest and darkest along its base and grades upward into cleaner, clay-depleted sand filling the bowl of the saucer.
- Vertical Progression Within a Single Bed: Across a thick dewatering sandstone unit, dish geometry evolves systematically from base to top. Near the base of the bed, dishes are wide (20–50 cm across), gently curved or nearly flat, and widely spaced. Moving upward into the middle and upper parts of the bed—where cumulative upward water flux increases—dishes become progressively narrower (3–10 cm across), more deeply concave (hemispherical or teacup-shaped), and more closely packed, with upturned rims that curl vertically into adjacent pillars.
Anatomy of Pillar Structures
Pillar structures are vertical, subvertical, or sinuous cylindrical sheets and pipes of homogeneous, unstratified sand that cut across primary lamination and dish horizons. Pillars range from 0.5 to 15 cm in width and from a few centimeters to more than 1 m in vertical height. They fall into two spatial subtypes:
- Type A (Inter-Dish Margin Pillars): Short, vertical escapeways located directly at the upturned junctions between adjacent dishes, formed where pore water deflected sideways beneath semi-permeable dish floors converged and broke upward around the dish rims.
- Type B (Through-Going Chimney Pillars): Larger, continuous vertical columns or planar curtains of elutriated, clean sand that cut across multiple stacked dish levels, bordered by thin, dark shear envelopes of vertically oriented mica flakes and clay platelets.
| Dewatering Horizon | Dish Width and Shape | Pillar Abundance | Hydrodynamic Regime | Equivalent Lowe / Bouma Division |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lower Bed Zone | Broad (20–50 cm), flat to slightly concave seams | Rare; minor upturned dish edges | Early onset of hindered settling and gentle upward seepage | Upper S2 / lower S3 traction-carpet transition |
| Middle Bed Zone | Intermediate (8–20 cm), distinct saucer-shaped bowls | Common inter-dish margin pillars (Type A) | Active semi-permeable barrier formation and lateral deflection | Main S3 suspension-fallout division |
| Upper-Middle Zone | Narrow (3–8 cm), deep teacup-shaped bowls with vertical rims | Abundant through-going vertical chimneys (Type B) | High cumulative fluid flux exceeding minimum fluidization velocity | Upper S3 / Bouma Ta–Tb transition |
| Top of Bed | Absent or replaced by convolute lamination | Sand volcanoes or truncation beneath Tc ripples | Waning fluid expulsion and re-establishment of bedload traction | Bouma Tc climbing-ripple / convolute division |
Fluid-Mechanical Origin: Seepage, Elutriation, and Fluidization
The formation of dish and pillar structures is governed by the interaction between hindered settling, Darcy seepage, and particulate fluidization as a loosely packed sand bed consolidates from an initial depositional porosity of n0 ≈ 45–52% down to a stable framework porosity of nf ≈ 35–38%. For a 2-meter-thick sand bed deposited within minutes from a high-density turbidity current, this 10–14% porosity reduction requires expelling roughly 0.20 to 0.28 m3 of pore water per square meter of bed area.
Stage 1: Upward Seepage and Clay-Lamella Filtration (Dish Genesis)
As the sand framework settles under gravity, displaced pore water migrates upward at a superficial Darcy velocity U below the minimum fluidization velocity (U < Umf). This upward seepage entrains microscopic interstitial clay floccules, organic fibrils, and fine biotite flakes (d < 20 μm) out of the sand pore throats—a process termed elutriation. Whenever the rising water encounters a subtle primary permeability contrast—such as a millimeter-scale grain-size lamina inherited from pulsating suspension fallout or traction-carpet freezing—the elutriated clay particles are trapped against the underside of the slightly finer lamina like cake on a filter screen.
As clay accumulates along this horizontal horizon, its local vertical hydraulic conductivity drops by 1 to 2 orders of magnitude. Blocked from passing directly through the clogging clay film, rising pore water builds up a localized overpressure beneath the seam and flows laterally toward the edges of the patch before breaking upward at its weak perimeter. Upward fluid drag at the perimeter bends the margins of the flexible, clay-enriched seam upward while overburden settling depresses its center, molding the originally flat lamina into a concave-upward dish. Meanwhile, the sand layer directly above the dish floor has been stripped of its interstitial clay by upward elutriation, explaining why the interior bowl of each dish consists of cleaner, lighter-colored quartzose sand.
Stage 2: Fluidization Breakthrough (Pillar Genesis)
As water diverted horizontally beneath dozens of stacked dishes converges at the dish edges—and as cumulative upward water discharge increases toward the upper half of the consolidating bed—the local vertical fluid velocity U in the inter-dish gaps surpasses the minimum fluidization velocity (Umf, typically 0.5 to 5 mm/s for fine to medium sand):
Umf ≈ [(ρs − ρf) g d2 n3] / [180 μ (1 − n)]
Once U ≥ Umf, upward fluid drag balances and exceeds the immersed weight of the sand grains. The granular framework loses all frictional strength and transforms into a turbulent, upward-streaming fluidized column. Within this vertical pipe, primary lamination is erased, fine clay is flushed completely out of the top of the bed (occasionally erupting onto the seafloor as a miniature sand volcano), and platy grains along the wall of the pipe rotate into vertical alignment, preserving the pillar structure once flow subsides and the grains repacked.
Environmental and Reservoir Significance
In petroleum and carbon-storage reservoir characterization of deep-water turbidite sandstones, dish and pillar structures exert a measurable control on permeability anisotropy (kv/kh). Dense horizons of broad, sub-horizontal clay dishes act as microscopic baffles that reduce vertical permeability (kv) relative to horizontal permeability (kh). Conversely, where abundant through-going Type B pillars pierce the dish horizons, the clean, clay-free sand columns act as vertical high-permeability conduits that restore vertical fluid connectivity across the bed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do dishes become smaller and deeper toward the top of a sandstone bed?
Near the base of a consolidating sand bed, only the pore water expelled from the lowest few centimeters passes upward, so fluid flux is modest and dishes remain broad and flat. Toward the upper part of the bed, the cumulative volume of water expelled from the entire underlying thickness must pass through the upper layers. This higher upward water discharge breaks the clay seams into smaller segments (3–10 cm wide) and exerts stronger upward drag around their edges, bending them into deep, teacup-shaped profiles pierced by numerous pillars.
Are dish structures primary depositional ripples or post-depositional dewatering features?
Although early observers occasionally mistook dish structures for trough cross-bedding or current ripples in outcrop, dish structures are post-depositional fluid-escape structures formed minutes to hours after sand deposition. Unlike current ripples, dishes lack internal foreset laminae, contain concentrated clay seams along their concave bases with clay-depleted sand directly above, and have upturned margins that grade directly into vertical fluid-escape pillars.
Can dish and pillar structures form in non-marine environments?
Yes. Although most abundant in deep-marine submarine canyon and fan-channel high-density turbidites, dish and pillar structures also form in subaerial and shallow-water settings wherever thick, water-saturated sand is deposited rapidly enough to trap excess pore fluid—including glacial outwash (jökulhlaup) flood sands, braided river flood bars, delta-front mouth bars, and pyroclastic surge deposits interacting with groundwater.
References
- Lowe, D. R., & LoPiccolo, R. D. (1974). The characteristics and origins of dish and pillar structures. Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, 44(2), 484–501. https://doi.org/10.1306/74D72A68-2B21-11D7-8648000102C1865D
- Lowe, D. R. (1975). Water escape structures in coarse-grained sediments. Sedimentology, 22(2), 157–204. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-3091.1975.tb00290.x
- Wentworth, C. M. (1967). Dish structure, a primary sedimentary structure in coarse turbidites. AAPG Bulletin, 51(3), 485. https://doi.org/10.1306/5D25C097-16C1-11D7-8645000102C1865D
- Hurst, A., & Cronin, B. T. (2001). The origin of laminar sand sheets and dish structures in deep-water sandstones. Sedimentology, 48(4), 863–879.