Giving-Up Density
Giving-Up Density is a quantitative metric in behavioral and community ecology defined as the density of food resources remaining in a depletable patch when a forager chooses to cease harvesting, where its marginal harvest rate equals the sum of its metabolic, predation-risk, and missed-opportunity costs.
Giving-Up Density (GUD) is a quantitative theoretical and experimental metric in behavioral ecology, community ecology, and optimal foraging theory defined as the density (or absolute amount) of food remaining inside a depletable resource patch at the exact moment a foraging animal decides to quit harvesting and depart the patch. Introduced in 1988 by American evolutionary ecologist Joel S. Brown in a landmark paper in Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology ("Patch use as an indicator of habitat preference, predation risk, and competition"), the Giving-Up Density framework extends Eric L. Charnov's (1976) Marginal Value Theorem from a single currency (maximizing net energy intake rate) to a unified multi-currency fitness equation that simultaneously incorporates thermoregulatory metabolic cost (C), perceived predation risk (P), and missed-opportunity cost (MOC).
Because a forager depleting a patch mixed with inedible substrate (such as millet seeds mixed into a tray of sifted desert sand, or browse twigs on a thorny shrub) experiences a monotonically declining instantaneous harvest rate (H) as food density (N) drops, the amount of food left behind when the animal walks or flies away provides an objective, quantitative "behavioral titration" of the animal's perceived costs and fears across the biosphere. Since 1988, Brown's GUD assay has become the standard empirical tool for mapping the Landscape of Fear (Laundré, Hernández, & Altendorf, 2001), measuring non-consumptive trophic cascades, and testing mechanisms of interspecific species coexistence across desert rodents, ungulates, primates, birds, and coral-reef fishes.
Brown's (1988) Fundamental Patch-Quit Equation (H = C + P + MOC)
Derivation from Fitness Maximization Under Predation Hazard
In 1988 and 1992, Joel S. Brown derived the optimal patch-quitting rule for a forager whose Darwinian fitness F(e, p) is the product of its survivorship probability (p) over the foraging period and its survivorship-dependent reproductive value (F[e]), which is a monotonically increasing function of net energy accumulated (e). While foraging inside a depletable patch with instantaneous predation hazard rate μ (probability of being killed per unit time), the forager harvests energy at rate H(N) (an increasing function of remaining food density N, typically following Holling's Type II disc equation; see Optimal Foraging Theory) while expending metabolic energy at rate c.
Maximizing expected fitness p · F(e) with respect to patch residence time proves that the forager should continue exploiting the patch so long as H > C + P + MOC, and should quit the patch at the threshold food density (N* = GUD) where its marginal harvest rate drops to equal the sum of three energetic-equivalent costs:
H(GUD) = C + P + MOC
- Metabolic Cost of Foraging (C): The net physiological energy expenditure per unit time required to actively search and handle food in the patch (above resting metabolism), including thermoregulatory heat loss in cold or windy microhabitats (see Hesse's Rule and allometric macroecology).
- Metabolic Equivalent Cost of Predation Risk (P): The "tax of fear" that converts the instantaneous probability of being killed by a predator (μ) into energy units via the ratio of total fitness F to the marginal fitness value of energy (∂F/∂e):
P = μ · F / (∂F / ∂e) Crucially, this formula explains state-dependent foraging: a fat, well-fed animal has a high baseline fitness F and a small marginal utility of one extra seed (∂F/∂e is small; compare Risk-Sensitive Foraging), making its predation cost P very high ("lots to lose"), so it quits risky patches early (high GUD). Conversely, a starving animal has F → 0 and a high marginal utility of energy ∂F/∂e, shrinking P toward zero ("nothing to lose") and driving the animal to harvest even predator-exposed trays down to the bare sand (low GUD).
- Missed-Opportunity Cost (MOC): The marginal value of the best alternative activity the forager foregoes by remaining in the current patch—such as foraging in richer neighboring patches (Charnov's background habitat rate in the Marginal Value Theorem), defending territory, courting mates, or resting in a thermal refuge.
| Experimental Manipulation / Environmental Factor | Cost Component Affected (C, P, or MOC) | Direction of Cost Shift | Predicted Change in Giving-Up Density (GUD) | Classic Field / Mesocosm Verification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Open Microhabitat vs. Protective Bush Cover | Predation Cost (P from owls) | Popen > Pbush (Owls strike in open) | Higher GUD in open; Lower GUD under bush | Kotler, Brown, & Hasson (1991) in Negev Desert gerbils (Gerbillus) |
| Full Moon Illumination vs. New Moon Darkness | Predation Cost (P from visual predators) | Pfull moon > Pnew moon | Higher GUD on bright full-moon nights | Bowers (1988); Kotler et al. (1991, 2010) in kangaroo rats & gerbils |
| Predator Urine / Odor or Direct Viper Presence | Predation Cost (P from snakes/mammals) | Pbush ↑ when vipers ambush under bushes | Reverses microhabitat GUD (Bush GUD rises) | Bouskila (1995); Kotler, Blaustein, & Brown (1992) with horned vipers |
| Subfreezing Ambient Temperature / High Wind | Metabolic Cost (C of thermoregulation) | Ccold > Cthermoneutral | Higher GUD in exposed cold microsites | Kilpatrick (2003); Orrock & Danielson in Peromyscus mice |
| Supplemental Background Food Added to Habitat | Missed-Opportunity Cost (MOC + State F) | MOC ↑ and energetic state F ↑ | Higher GUD across all experimental trays | Brown (1988); Olsson et al. in desert rodents & woodpeckers |
How Experimentalists Measure Giving-Up Densities in the Field
To turn H(GUD) = C + P + MOC into a quantitative field instrument, Joel S. Brown (1988) and Burt P. Kotler designed the depletable artificial food tray (seed tray):
- A flat aluminum or plastic tray (typically 30 × 40 cm) is filled with a fixed volume (e.g., 3 to 5 liters) of an inert, inedible particulate substrate—such as sifted dune sand for desert rodents, plastic beads or wood chips for squirrels and birds, or artificial turf—into which a precise initial mass (e.g., 3.00 g) of husked millet seeds is thoroughly mixed.
- Why mix the seeds into sand? If seeds were simply piled on a bare plate, the forager's harvest rate H would remain constant until the last seed was eaten, and the animal would always eat 100% of the seeds or 0% (an uninformative step function). By burying the seeds uniformly in sand, every seed found and removed reduces the density of the remaining seeds, forcing the animal to dig through more sand for each subsequent seed (diminishing returns: ∂H/∂N > 0, matching Holling's Type II curve).
- At dawn (after nocturnal rodent foraging) or dusk (after diurnal squirrel/bird foraging), the researcher records the species identity of the tracks in the sand, sifts the remaining seeds out of the tray, and weighs the residual seed mass (the GUD, in grams).
- By placing paired trays just 1 to 2 meters apart—for example, one tray tucked beneath a thorny desert shrub ("bush") and an identical tray 1.5 m away in the open sand ("open")—both trays share the exact same background climate (C) and the exact same territory-wide missed-opportunity cost (MOC). Consequently, the difference in leftover seeds (GUDopen − GUDbush) isolates the exact quantitative value of microhabitat predation risk (Popen − Pbush).
Ecological Discoveries Powered by Giving-Up Densities
1. Mapping the "Landscape of Fear" and Predator Facilitation (Kotler, Blaustein, & Brown, 1991–1995)
In a celebrated series of large aviary and field experiments in the Negev Desert of Israel (Kotler, Brown, & Hasson, 1991; Kotler, Blaustein, & Brown, 1992) and the Mojave Desert (Amos Bouskila, 1995), researchers used GUD seed trays to test how desert rodents—Allenby's gerbil (Gerbillus andersoni allenbyi), the greater Egyptian sand gerbil (Gerbillus pyramidum), and Merriam's kangaroo rat (Dipodomys merriami)—navigate conflicting predators:
- Avian Predators (Barn Owls Tyto alba) & Moonlight: Owls hunt from the air by vision and hearing, striking rodents cleanly in open sand while being blocked by shrub branches. When barn owls were present—or when natural illumination increased from new moon to full moon—gerbils raised their GUDs significantly in open trays relative to bush trays, quantifying their fear of aerial attack.
- Reptilian Ambush Predators (Sahara Horned Vipers Cerastes cerastes & Sidewinders Crotalus cerastes): Unlike owls, sit-and-wait vipers coil in the shade beneath desert shrubs to ambush rodents fleeing into cover. When horned vipers were introduced under bushes, gerbils elevated their bush GUDs to match open GUDs. Thus, owls and vipers exert predator facilitation: the owl's aerial threat drives gerbils out of the open and directly into the ambush zone of the bush-dwelling viper.
2. Coexistence Mechanisms in Desert Rodent Guilds (Brown, Kotler, & Mitchell, 1994)
Classical niche theory struggled to explain how multiple granivorous rodent species coexist on the exact same seed resource in desert ecosystems. Using GUD trays across seasons and microhabitats in the Sonoran, Mojave, and Negev deserts, Joel S. Brown, Burt P. Kotler, and William A. Mitchell proved two fundamental coexistence mechanisms (compare modern coexistence theory and resource partitioning):
- Bipedal vs. Quadrupedal Microhabitat Partitioning: Bipedal kangaroo rats (Dipodomys) and jerboas possess enlarged auditory bullae (detecting owl wingbeats) and erratic bipedal saltatory leaps that lower their predation risk P in open microhabitats, giving them the lowest GUDs in open sand. Conversely, quadrupedal pocket mice (Chaetodipus and Perognathus) move stealthily through tangled branches, giving them lower GUDs under bushes.
- Seasonal Rotating Foraging Efficiency (Body Size vs. Metabolic Cost C): In the Negev Desert, the larger Gerbillus pyramidum (40 g) dominates rich patches right after evening windstorms blow sand over seed banks, then quits at a high GUD because its absolute metabolic requirement (M0.75; see Jarman–Bell Principle) is high; the smaller Gerbillus allenbyi (26 g) has a lower absolute metabolic maintenance cost C, allowing it to profitably "cream-skim" and deplete the leftover patches down to a lower GUD (cream-skimmer vs. crumb-picker coexistence).
3. Conservation Biology, Ecotourism, and Cancer Ecology
Beyond rodent guilds, the Giving-Up Density framework has been expanded to:
- Ungulate Browsing and Large Carnivore Reintroduction: Measuring stem diameter at the point where deer or elk stop browsing twigs (twig-diameter GUD) or behavioral patch-use responses in African savannas (e.g., Valeix et al., 2009; Altendorf et al., 2001) to map how wolves (Canis lupus) and lions (Panthera leo) create spatial refuges for woody tree regeneration via trophic cascades.
- Lesser Spotted Woodpeckers as Indicator Species (Olsson, Brown, & Smith, 2002): Measuring the density of mealworms left inside artificial drilled wooden branches by lesser spotted woodpeckers (Dryobates minor) in Swedish forests; woodpeckers in degraded, food-poor territories exhibit much lower GUDs (higher desperation) than woodpeckers in intact old-growth territories, providing a rapid behavioral bioassay of habitat quality long before population crash.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does a higher Giving-Up Density (GUD) indicate a worse or riskier habitat?
Because Giving-Up Density (GUD) measures the amount of food left behind uneaten when the animal quits the patch. If a patch is safe, warm, and comfortable (low P and low C), the animal stays a long time and eats almost every seed, leaving very little behind (a low GUD). If the patch is exposed to owls or freezing cold (high P or high C), the animal demands a high harvest rate H to justify staying; as soon as the easiest top seeds are skimmed off, the animal flees, leaving a large pile of seeds behind (a high GUD).
What is the difference between Giving-Up Time (GUT) and Giving-Up Density (GUD)?
Proposed in early tests of Charnov's Marginal Value Theorem (such as Krebs, Ryan, & Charnov, 1974), Giving-Up Time (GUT) is the time interval elapsed since the last prey capture before a predator decides a patch is empty and leaves. As Joel S. Brown (1988) and Richard F. Green (1984) demonstrated, whenever a forager can assess patch depletion continuously (or when capture rates are high), quitting at a fixed Giving-Up Density (GUD)—where instantaneous marginal harvest rate H(GUD) equals C + P + MOC—is mathematically superior to using a fixed time-since-last-capture rule.
How can researchers tell whether a low GUD means the microhabitat is safe (low P) versus the animal is starving (low MOC / low state F)?
By comparing spatial scales. When two trays are placed 1.5 meters apart (one under a bush, one in the open) within the same individual's home range on the same night, the same animal visits both trays in the same physiological hunger state (F) and with the same territory-wide missed-opportunity cost (MOC); thus, the within-pair difference (GUDopen − GUDbush) purely measures microhabitat predation risk (P). Conversely, comparing the average GUD of bush trays across two different forests (or between summer and winter) measures territory-wide resource richness and energetic state (MOC and ∂F/∂e).
References
- Brown, J. S. (Jan 1988). Patch use as an indicator of habitat preference, predation risk, and competition. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 22(1), 37–47. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00395696
- Kotler, B. P., Brown, J. S., & Hasson, O. (Dec 1991). Factors affecting gerbil foraging behavior and rates of owl predation. Ecology, 72(6), 2249–2260. https://doi.org/10.2307/1941575
- Brown, J. S., & Kotler, B. P. (Oct 2004; published online Sep 15, 2004). Hazardous duty pay and the foraging cost of predation. Ecology Letters, 7(10), 999–1014. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1461-0248.2004.00661.x
- Laundré, J. W., Hernández, L., & Altendorf, K. B. (Aug 1, 2001). Wolves, elk, and bison: reestablishing the "landscape of fear" in Yellowstone National Park, U.S.A. Canadian Journal of Zoology, 79(8), 1401–1409. https://doi.org/10.1139/z01-094
- Valeix, M., Fritz, H., Loveridge, A. J., Davidson, Z., Hunt, J. E., Murindagomo, F., & Macdonald, D. W. (Aug 2009; published online Mar 31, 2009). Does the risk of encountering lions influence African herbivore behaviour at waterholes? Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 63(10), 1483–1494. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-009-0760-3