Nordhaus DICE Model
The DICE model is an integrated assessment framework created by William Nordhaus that couples neoclassical economic growth with carbon-cycle climate dynamics to calculate the social cost of carbon and optimal emission pathways.
The DICE model (Dynamic Integrated Climate-Economy model) is an integrated assessment framework formulated by Nobel laureate William D. Nordhaus in the early 1990s. First published in Science in 1992 and detailed in The American Economic Review in 1993, the DICE model was the first quantitative economic model to couple a neoclassical Ramsey growth macroeconomic engine with a multi-reservoir geophysical carbon cycle and global temperature response functions. Designed to calculate the Social Cost of Carbon (SCC) and evaluate optimal carbon pricing policies, DICE became the global benchmark for climate-economy policy analysis and earned Nordhaus the 2018 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences.
Architecture of Coupled Economic and Climate Modules
The architecture of the DICE model operates as a closed feedback loop between human industrial production, greenhouse gas emissions, atmospheric warming, and resultant economic damages:
1. The Macroeconomic Engine (Ramsey Growth)
The economic core of DICE is a global neoclassical Ramsey–Cass–Koopmans growth model. Global economic output Y(t) is generated via an aggregate Cobb–Douglas production function combining capital K(t), labor L(t), and total factor productivity A(t):
Y(t) = A(t) K(t)γ L(t)1 - γ
Gross output is reduced by two climate-related factors: industrial abatement expenditures Λ(t) and climate damage fraction Ω(t):
Ynet(t) = [1 - Ω(t)] [1 - Λ(t)] Y(t)
Net output is allocated between immediate consumption C(t) and gross investment I(t), which drives the capital accumulation transition equation:
K(t+1) = (1 - δ) K(t) + I(t)
The global social planner maximizes the discounted sum of population-weighted utility:
W = Σt=0T U[c(t)] L(t) (1 + ρ)-t
where c(t) = C(t) / L(t) is per capita consumption, ρ is the pure rate of social time preference, and the period utility function exhibits constant relative risk aversion: U(c) = (c1 - η) / (1 - η).
2. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Abatement
Industrial carbon dioxide emissions Eind(t) are proportional to gross economic output, governed by an endogenous carbon intensity parameter σ(t) and the fractional emission reduction rate μ(t) (where 0 ≤ μ(t) ≤ 1):
Eind(t) = σ(t) [1 - μ(t)] Y(t)
Total emissions E(t) include land-use and deforestation emissions Eland(t):
E(t) = Eind(t) + Eland(t)
The cost of reducing emissions by fraction μ(t) is governed by an abatement cost function:
Λ(t) = θ1(t) μ(t)θ2
where θ2 ≈ 2.6 to 2.8, reflecting rising marginal abatement costs as an economy moves toward full decarbonization.
3. The Geophysical Carbon Cycle and Radiative Forcing
DICE tracks carbon exchange across three interconnected reservoirs: the atmosphere (MAT), the upper ocean/biosphere (MUP), and the deep ocean (MLO). The atmospheric carbon accumulation follows a linear Markov transition matrix:
MAT(t+1) = E(t) + φ11 MAT(t) + φ21 MUP(t)
Accumulated atmospheric carbon increases radiative forcing F(t) according to the logarithmic greenhouse warming equation:
F(t) = ηf [ ln(MAT(t) / MAT,1750) / ln(2) ] + Fext(t)
where ηf ≈ 3.68 W/m2 is the radiative forcing resulting from a doubling of pre-industrial atmospheric CO2 concentrations, and Fext(t) represents exogenous non-CO2 forcings.
4. Climate Warming and the Damage Function
Atmospheric radiative forcing warms the global mean surface temperature TAT(t) and deep ocean temperature TLO(t) through a two-layer heat diffusion system parameterized by equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS ≈ 3.0°C per CO2 doubling).
Economic damage Ω(t) is parameterized as a quadratic function of surface temperature anomaly TAT(t):
Ω(t) = ψ1 TAT(t) + ψ2 [TAT(t)]2
This damage fraction captures agricultural yield reductions, sea-level rise coastal adaptation costs, extreme weather damages, and public health mortality.
Calculating the Social Cost of Carbon (SCC)
The central operational output of the DICE model is the Social Cost of Carbon (SCC), defined as the marginal economic damage caused by emitting one additional metric ton of carbon dioxide at time $t$, expressed in present monetary value:
SCC(t) = - [ (∂W / ∂E(t)) / (∂W / ∂C(t)) ]
In optimal policy simulations, the social cost of carbon defines the optimal carbon price (such as a global carbon tax or cap-and-trade permit price) required to internalize climate externalities along the cost-benefit frontier.
The Discounting Debate: Nordhaus vs. Stern
The DICE model became the central battleground in the famous discounting controversy between William Nordhaus and Nicholas Stern (author of the 2006 Stern Review):
- Nordhaus's Descriptive Approach: Nordhaus set the pure rate of time preference at ρ ≈ 1.5% per year and consumption curvature η ≈ 1.45, matching observed real market returns on capital (r ≈ 4%–5%). Under this descriptive discounting, future climate damages occurring a century from now are discounted substantially, yielding a modest initial SCC ($30 to $50 per ton of CO2) and recommending a gradual "climate policy ramp."
- Stern's Prescriptive Approach: Stern argued on ethical grounds that future generations should be valued equally with the present, setting ρ ≈ 0.1%. This near-zero discount rate produces an effective discount rate of roughly 1.4%, yielding a massive initial SCC ($200+ per ton of CO2) and demanding immediate radical emission reductions.
Modern Revisions and Regional Extensions (RICE)
Nordhaus and collaborating research teams continually updated the DICE framework (culminating in DICE-2016R and DICE-2023). Furthermore, Nordhaus developed the RICE model (Regional Integrated model of Climate and the Economy), which disaggregates the global economy into 12 distinct geopolitical regions (such as the United States, European Union, China, and India), enabling the analysis of international climate negotiations, carbon leakage, and differentiated regional impacts.
Integrated assessment models derived from DICE are employed by governmental agencies worldwide, including the United States Interagency Working Group on the Social Cost of Greenhouse Gases, providing the empirical foundation for environmental cost-benefit rulemaking.
References
- Nordhaus, W. D. (1992). An Optimal Transition Path for Controlling Greenhouse Gases. Science, 258(5086), 1315–1319.
- Nordhaus, W. D. (1993). Rolling the 'DICE': An Optimal Transition Path for Controlling Greenhouse Gases. The American Economic Review, 83(2), 11–17.
- Nordhaus, W. D. (2017). Revisiting the social cost of carbon. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114(7), 1518–1523.