Experimental Lakes Area Eutrophication
Experimental Lakes Area Eutrophication refers to the whole-ecosystem lake manipulations directed by David W. Schindler in northwestern Ontario that proved phosphorus—rather than carbon or nitrogen—is the primary limiting nutrient driving freshwater cultural eutrophication.
Experimental Lakes Area Eutrophication encompasses a landmark series of whole-ecosystem nutrient manipulations conducted beginning in 1968 at the Experimental Lakes Area (ELA, now the IISD Experimental Lakes Area) in the boreal Precambrian Shield of northwestern Ontario, Canada, under the scientific leadership of limnologist David W. Schindler and colleague John R. Vallentyne. Established by the Fisheries Research Board of Canada across 58 small, pristine oligotrophic headwater lakes, the ELA whole-lake fertilization experiments—most famously Lake 226 and Lake 227—resolved the "Carbon–Phosphorus Controversy" of the late 1960s and 1970s. By demonstrating at the full ecosystem scale that dissolved inorganic carbon (CO2) and dinitrogen gas (N2) invade fertilized lakes directly from the atmosphere to balance cellular ecological stoichiometry, Schindler proved that phosphorus (P) is the master limiting nutrient governing freshwater cultural eutrophication and cyanobacterial harmful algal blooms.
The Carbon–Phosphorus Controversy (1967–1973)
During the 1960s, severe summer blooms of nuisance cyanobacteria (Dolichospermum, Aphanizomenon, and Microcystis), hypolimnetic oxygen depletion, and fish kills degraded North America's Laurentian Great Lakes—particularly Lake Erie—and European alpine lakes. Because healthy phytoplankton biomass requires carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus in an approximate molar Redfield ratio of 106 C : 16 N : 1 P (or ~40:7:1 by mass), phosphate detergent manufacturers argued that carbon—not phosphorus from sodium tripolyphosphate (Na5P3O10) laundry detergents and municipal sewage—was the primary limiting nutrient in soft-water lakes.
Proponents of the carbon-limitation hypothesis relied on short-term (4-hour) bottle bioassays, in which sealing lake water inside glass BOD bottles with added phosphate and nitrate rapidly exhausted the small dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) pool of low-alkalinity water, arresting photosynthesis unless bicarbonate (HCO3−) was also added. Schindler recognized that sealed glass bottles created a physical artifact by isolating the water column from the atmosphere and benthic sediments, eliminating gas exchange at the air–water interface and microbial transformations such as nitrification, comammox, and denitrification. To test nutrient limitation without bottle artifacts, the Canadian government designated 58 small boreal shield lakes near Kenora, Ontario, for whole-lake experimental manipulations.
Whole-Lake Fertilization of Lake 227 and Split-Basin Lake 226
Lake 227: Atmospheric CO2 Invasion and N-Fixation Compensation
Beginning in 1969, Schindler's team fertilized Lake 227—a 5.0-hectare oligotrophic lake with bolster-low ambient dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC ≈ 40–120 μmol L−1)—exclusively with nitrogen and phosphorus (initially at a molar N:P ratio of 31:1 from 1969–1974, reduced to 11:1 from 1975–1989, and finally 0:1 phosphorus alone from 1990 onward) while adding zero organic or inorganic carbon. Within weeks of the first N + P additions, phytoplankton chlorophyll a increased 10- to 50-fold, shifting the lake from net heterotrophy fueled by allochthonous and autochthonous carbon to intense net autotrophy that raised epilimnetic pH above 9.5–10.0.
As intense daytime photosynthesis depleted dissolved CO2(aq) below atmospheric equilibrium (~10–15 μmol L−1), a steep partial-pressure gradient drove rapid invasion of atmospheric CO2 across the air–water interface, reinforced by chemical enhancement as invading CO2 reacted directly with hydroxide ions (CO2 + OH− → HCO3−) at high pH. Using sulfur hexafluoride (SF6) and radon-222 (222Rn) gas-exchange tracers, Schindler demonstrated that atmospheric CO2 invasion supplied 70–90% of the carbon incorporated into algal biomass, refuting the claim that low-DIC lakes are carbon-limited.
Furthermore, when the experimental N:P fertilizer ratio in Lake 227 was lowered from 31:1 to 11:1 in 1975—and when nitrogen fertilization was halted completely in 1990, leaving phosphorus as the sole added nutrient for more than three decades—total phytoplankton biomass and summer eutrophication did not decline. Instead, nitrogen limitation selected for heterocystous diazotrophic (N2-fixing) cyanobacteria (Aphanizomenon schindleri and Dolichospermum), which reduced atmospheric dinitrogen gas (N2 → 2 NH3) via the nitrogenase enzyme complex to make up the nitrogen deficit, maintaining summer blooms as long as phosphorus was supplied.
| Experimental Lake & Basin | Nutrient Treatment | Molar N:P Input Ratio | Dominant Phytoplankton Response | Ecosystem & Policy Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lake 226 South Basin (Control) | Carbon (sucrose) + Nitrogen (NO3−) only | ∞ (Zero P added) | Oligotrophic baseline (Chlorophyll a ≈ 2–4 μg L−1); chrysophytes & diatoms | C + N additions without phosphorus fail to trigger algal blooms |
| Lake 226 North Basin (Treated) | Carbon + Nitrogen + Phosphorus (PO43−) | ~11:1 to 13:1 | Dense Dolichospermum cyanobacterial bloom (Chlorophyll a > 40–60 μg L−1) | Visual proof that phosphorus controls eutrophication |
| Lake 227 (1969–1974) | High N + P (Zero C added) | 31:1 | Non-diazotrophic chlorophytes & Oscillatoria blooms; atmospheric CO2 invasion | Atmospheric CO2 gas exchange overcomes DIC limitation |
| Lake 227 (1975–1989) | Low N + P (Zero C added) | 11:1 (Below Redfield 16:1) | Shift to heterocystous N2-fixing cyanobacteria (Aphanizomenon) | Low N:P selects for diazotrophic cyanobacterial dominance |
| Lake 227 (1990–Present) | Phosphorus only (Zero C, Zero N) | 0:1 | Sustained summer N2-fixing cyanobacterial blooms for >30 years | Nitrogen reduction alone without P control cannot prevent freshwater blooms |
Lake 226 (1973): The Split-Lake Curtain Experiment
To create a definitive visual and controlled comparison within a single waterbody, Schindler partitioned hourglass-shaped Lake 226 (16.1 hectares) in 1973 using a heavy vinyl sea-curtain sealed across its central bedrock narrows. The southwest basin (Lake 226S) received weekly additions of carbon (sucrose) and nitrogen (sodium nitrate), while the northeast basin (Lake 226N) received the identical doses of carbon and nitrogen plus phosphorus (orthophosphate, 0.59 g P m−2 yr−1).
Within weeks, the phosphorus-enriched northeast basin turned pea-soup green with a dense surface bloom of the nitrogen-fixing cyanobacterium Dolichospermum spiroides (formerly Anabaena spiroides), diminishing Secchi disk transparency from >4 m to <1.0 m and altering energy transfer governed by Lindeman's trophic efficiency law, while the C+N-only southwest basin remained crystal clear at pre-treatment oligotrophic chlorophyll concentrations. Schindler's aerial photograph of the bright green northeast basin separated by a thin curtain from the dark blue southwest basin published in Science (1974) became one of the most influential images in environmental science, catalyzing the 1972/1978 U.S.–Canada Great Lakes Water Quality Agreements, legislated bans on phosphate laundry detergents, and tertiary phosphorus precipitation (via ferric chloride or alum) at municipal wastewater treatment plants worldwide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why can freshwater ecosystems compensate for carbon and nitrogen shortages but not phosphorus shortages?
Both carbon and nitrogen possess vast gaseous atmospheric reservoirs—atmospheric CO2 (~425 ppm) and atmospheric N2 (78.08% of the atmosphere)—that can diffuse across the air–water interface and be fixed biologically by oxygenic phototrophs (via RuBisCO) and diazotrophic cyanobacteria (via nitrogenase). In contrast, phosphorus has no stable gaseous phase at Earth surface temperatures (phosphine, PH3, is a trace gas). Consequently, once dissolved orthophosphate (PO43−) is exhausted in the epilimnion and exported via sinking detritus to the profundal sediment, phytoplankton have no atmospheric reservoir from which to replenish phosphorus.
Why do some estuarine and coastal marine waters still require dual nitrogen and phosphorus management?
In high-salinity estuarine and coastal marine ecosystems, biological N2 fixation by planktonic cyanobacteria is frequently constrained by high sulfate (SO42−) concentrations (which inhibit molybdate MoO42− uptake required for the FeMo-cofactor of nitrogenase), dissolved iron scarcity, and rapid benthic denitrification losses. Because marine diazotrophs cannot always make up an anthropogenic nitrogen deficit over short estuarine residence times, managing coastal hypoxia and harmful algal blooms along continental shelves often requires dual reductions of both phosphorus and nitrogen loads.
References
- Schindler, D. W., Armstrong, F. A. J., Holmgren, S. K., & Brunskill, G. J. (1971). "Eutrophication of Lake 227, Experimental Lakes Area, northwestern Ontario, by addition of phosphate and nitrate." Journal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada, 28(11), 1763–1782. https://doi.org/10.1139/f71-261
- Schindler, D. W. (1974). "Eutrophication and recovery in experimental lakes: Implications for lake management." Science, 184(4139), 897–899. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.184.4139.897
- Schindler, D. W. (1977). "Evolution of phosphorus limitation in lakes." Science, 195(4275), 260–262. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.195.4275.260
- Schindler, D. W., Hecky, R. E., Findlay, D. L., et al. (2008). "Eutrophication of lakes cannot be controlled by reducing nitrogen input: Results of a 37-year whole-ecosystem experiment." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 105(32), 11254–11258. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0805108105