โ† Wiki Index / Entertainment / The Bulpington of Blup
๐ŸŽฌ Entertainment

The Bulpington of Blup

The Bulpington of Blup is a 1932 novel by H. G. Wells that follows Theodore Bulpington, a man who builds a romantic fantasy of himself and defends it against every contrary fact, offering a fictional case study in self-deception and rationalization across the First World War and its aftermath.

The Bulpington of Blup is a 1932 novel by H. G. Wells, published by Hutchinson in London and Macmillan in New York, that traces the life of Theodore Bulpington from an Edwardian suburban childhood through the First World War into the disillusioned 1920s. Wells conceived the book as a portrait of a mind that refuses reality: Theodore sustains an inflated picture of himself as a heroic, misunderstood figure, and repeatedly reinterprets failure, cowardice, and contradiction so that the picture survives. The novel contains no speculative technology of the kind that made Wells famous for The Time Machine or The War of the Worlds. Its relevance to science lies in psychology, because the plot dramatizes mechanisms later studied empirically as motivated reasoning, self-serving bias, and defensive rationalization, while its author uses the narrative to argue about how human beings come to hold false beliefs about themselves and the world.

Publication and Context

By 1932 Wells was in his mid-sixties, an established popularizer of science and social planning who had co-authored The Science of Life with Julian Huxley and G. P. Wells in 1930. After that encyclopedic project, he returned to novels centered on character. The Bulpington of Blup appeared during the global economic depression and the rise of fascist movements, a period in which Wells worried that irrational belief threatened democratic institutions. He viewed his protagonist as a type: an educated man whose intelligence serves his vanity rather than the truth. The strange title derives from the grandiose family name Theodore invents for himself, a "Bulpington of Blup," a flourish that signals fantasy as identity.

Plot Summary

Theodore grows up in a household divided between his romantic, impractical mother and the stolid practical culture around him. At school and in early adulthood he develops an inner world in which he is a chivalrous hero. When the First World War begins, he enlists, but the reality of trench conditions conflicts with his romantic self-image. He leaves the fighting under circumstances that he privately interprets as honorable and others interpret as breakdown. Afterward he marries, drifts through intellectual circles, and meets people who dispense political or scientific ideas he finds uncomfortable. At each juncture he selects explanations that protect his self-esteem, dismisses critics as philistines, and sinks deeper into fantasy. The book ends without redemption, leaving the reader to recognize the cost of a life organized around an unexamined story.

Wells's Argument and Characterization

Wells models Theodore through free indirect narration, allowing the character's rationalizations to appear persuasive before the narrator undercuts them with irony. The device exposes the gap between narrative and fact, inviting readers to practice the critical skepticism Wells advocated in his nonfiction. Secondary characters represent contrasting responses to the war and to modernity: scientists committed to evidence, political theorists committed to doctrine, and artistic figures committed to image. Wells sets the scientific temperament, which revises beliefs when evidence demands, against Theodore's temperament, which revises evidence to preserve beliefs.

It matters that the novel is a work of fiction. The psychology is Wells's literary intuition, informed by the early twentieth-century discussions of Freud, Janet, and Adler that circulated in British intellectual life, not an experimental demonstration. Events, motives, and outcomes are authored, so the book cannot test whether people actually behave as Theodore does.

Established Science of Self-Deception

Empirical psychology gives a more precise picture of the phenomena Wells dramatized, though in a quite different register.

  • Motivated reasoning. Experimental work, notably by Ziva Kunda in 1990, shows that people recruit cognitive strategies to arrive at conclusions they prefer, constrained by the need to appear reasonable. They search memory selectively and apply stricter standards to unwelcome evidence. This accords with Theodore's pattern, but the experimental effect is modest and context dependent, not an all-consuming delusion.
  • Self-serving attributional bias. Meta-analyses indicate that individuals tend to credit success to disposition and failure to circumstance, a tendency that varies across cultures and depressive states. Theodore exaggerates this tendency to a pathological degree.
  • Cognitive dissonance. Leon Festinger's 1957 theory proposes that holding contradictory cognitions generates discomfort that people reduce by changing beliefs or adding justifications, a mechanism visible in the character's rationalizations of wartime conduct.
  • Memory distortion. Autobiographical recall is reconstructive, and self-relevant memories are reshaped to fit current self-concepts. Studies of recall bias in epidemiology document how memory errors skew reports of past exposures, a more modest cousin of Theodore's revisionism.
  • Impression management. Social desirability bias describes the tendency to present oneself favorably in surveys and interviews, partly deliberate and partly sincere self-deception.

Evolutionary accounts, such as Robert Trivers's proposal that self-deception evolved to facilitate deceiving others, remain hypotheses with mixed empirical support. Whether any adaptive benefit outweighs costs of detachment from reality is debated, and the adaptive story is related to broader questions about whether cognitive biases are products of natural selection or byproducts of limited processing capacity.

Separating Fiction from Science

Wells's narrative compresses decades into a coherent downward arc. Real self-deception is variable, partial, and often adaptive in moderation: mild positive illusions correlate with well-being in some studies, and the weight of evidence does not support a single inexorable trajectory toward ruin. The novel also treats Theodore's wartime behavior as character failure, whereas contemporary research on combat stress recognizes physiological and psychological injury, a category that Wells's period only partly acknowledged as shell shock. Readers should therefore treat the book as a literary hypothesis about vanity, an illustration for epistemological reflection on how beliefs track evidence, and not as an empirical account of psychopathology.

Methodological Notes for Readers

Treating a novel as evidence about the mind requires caution about three points. First, selection: an author chooses episodes that illustrate a thesis, so no base rates can be inferred from a plot. Second, hindsight: narrative closure suggests that a person's fate follows inevitably from character, whereas empirical life-course research stresses chance events and the interaction of dispositions with circumstances. Third, measurement: Wells infers inner states from behavior and narration, while modern studies use validated scales, behavioral tasks, and preregistered designs to separate self-deception from simple error or deliberate lying. A reader who keeps these distinctions in view can enjoy the novel as literature and also use it to ask which of its psychological claims could be tested, such as whether people with inflated self-views resist corrective feedback more than others, a question that has been examined with mixed results in studies of narcissism and self-enhancement.

Reception and Legacy

Critical response was mixed. Reviewers admired the psychological acuity of the portrait while noting that Wells's didactic impulses intruded. In later decades the novel was overshadowed by his scientific romances, but it has been revisited by scholars of modernism and war literature as an example of the interwar fascination with self-narration. For students of science communication, the book offers a vivid reminder that cognitive bias is not only an experimental concept but also a narrative problem: people tell stories about themselves, and the stories can resist correction.

References

  1. Wells, H. G. (1932). The Bulpington of Blup. London: Hutchinson. Archive record: https://archive.org/details/bulpingtonofblup0000hgwe_x5r6
  2. Kunda, Z. (1990). The case for motivated reasoning. Psychological Bulletin, 108(3), 480โ€“498. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.108.3.480
  3. Festinger, L. (1957). A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. Stanford University Press.
  4. Festinger, L., & Carlsmith, J. M. (1959, March). Cognitive consequences of forced compliance. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 58(2), 203โ€“210. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0041593
  5. von Hippel, W., & Trivers, R. (2011). The evolution and psychology of self-deception. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 34(1), 1โ€“16. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X10001354
๐Ÿงฌ Support Open Science
Explore interactive science games on LowKey Games or browse scientific apparel & accessories in the CRV Science Shop.
๐Ÿ’ก Spot an inaccuracy or have primary literature to expand this article?
Submit a citation or revision note using your shared CRV Science / LowKey Games profile ID.
Suggest Revision