Eddington Approximation
The Eddington approximation is a classic radiative-transfer closure relation assuming near-isotropic radiation fields in stellar and planetary atmospheres, relating radiation pressure to mean intensity.
The Eddington approximation is a foundational analytical closure relation in astrophysical radiative transfer introduced by Arthur Stanley Eddington in 1926 to solve how photons diffuse through stellar interiors and plane-parallel planetary atmospheres. By assuming that the specific intensity of radiation varies only linearly with the cosine of the viewing angle (the two-stream or first-order Legendre moment approximation), the method relates the second angular moment of radiation—radiation pressure—directly to the zeroth moment, mean intensity, reducing integro-differential transfer equations into tractable differential equations.
Angular Moments and the Closure Relation
In a plane-parallel atmosphere parameterized by vertical optical depth τ and angle cosine μ = cos θ relative to the outward normal, three angular moments characterize the radiation field:
- Zeroth moment (J): Mean intensity, proportional to radiant energy density.
- First moment (H): Net outward radiative flux divided by 4π.
- Second moment (K): Radiation pressure integral divided by 4π.
Evaluating the moments of the radiative transfer equation yields two coupled differential equations containing three unknowns (J, H, K). Eddington closed this hierarchy by approximating the angular distribution of specific intensity as I(τ, μ) ≈ a(τ) + b(τ) μ, which directly enforces the Eddington closure:
K(τ) = (1 / 3) * J(τ)
equivalently expressed via the Eddington factor f = K / J = 1/3.
Physical Validity in Optically Thick Regimes
Deep inside stellar interiors and lower planetary atmospheres (τ >> 1), frequent photon absorption and scattering drive the radiation field toward near-isotropy, making K = J/3 accurate to high precision. Near the outer boundary (τ ≈ 0), however, photons stream outward into empty space with zero inward intensity, causing the true Eddington factor f = K/J to rise from 1/3 toward 1.0 in spherically extended envelopes.
Gray Atmosphere Temperature Profile
Applying the Eddington approximation to a plane-parallel gray atmosphere in local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) and radiative equilibrium yields the celebrated Eddington temperature-optical depth relation:
T4(τ) = (3 / 4) * Teff4 * (τ + 2 / 3)
where Teff is the star's effective temperature. Setting τ = 2/3 gives T(τ = 2/3) = Teff, explaining why a star's effective temperature corresponds closely to the physical gas temperature at optical depth two-thirds, while the surface boundary temperature (τ = 0) approaches (1/2)1/4 Teff ≈ 0.841 Teff.
Two-Stream Boundary Conditions
At the top boundary τ = 0, enforcing zero inward flux in a two-stream formulation sets J(0) = 2 H(0) (matching the Milne problem surface relation within a few percent of the exact Chandrasekhar discrete-ordinate value J(0) = √3 H(0)).
Modern Computational Extensions
While modern stellar-atmosphere codes (such as PHOENIX, ATLAS, and TLUSTY) and general-relativistic radiation-hydrodynamics simulations solve multi-angle, non-LTE radiative transfer numerically, variable Eddington factor (VEF) and M1 closure methods generalize Eddington's original moment approach to anisotropic accretion disks, core-collapse supernovae, and cosmological reionization fronts by computing f(τ, r) self-consistently from formal ray-tracing solutions.
Spherical Geometry and Limb Darkening
In plane-parallel stellar photospheres, the Eddington gray temperature profile T4(τ) = (3/4) Teff4 (τ + 2/3) directly predicts solar and stellar limb darkening—the observed phenomenon whereby the center of a stellar disk appears brighter and hotter than its outer limb. Along a viewing ray inclined at angle θ (with μ = cos θ), an observer sees down to unit slant optical depth (τ = μ). Rays near disk center (μ = 1) probe deeper, hotter atmospheric layers at τ = 1, whereas rays near the limb (μ → 0) sample cooler upper layers near τ = 0, yielding the classic linear Eddington limb-darkening law I(μ) / I(1) = (2 + 3μ) / 5.
Breakdown in Extended Supergiant Envelopes
When a star possesses a geometrically thick, tenuous outer envelope—such as a red supergiant, Wolf–Rayet wind, or asymptotic giant branch (AGB) star—the plane-parallel assumption fails because photon paths diverge radially across curved atmospheric shells. In spherical geometry, radiation becomes increasingly forward-peaked as optical depth drops, driving the Eddington factor f = K/J smoothly from 1/3 deep inside the envelope toward 1.0 in the free-streaming outer wind.
Two-Stream Radiative Equilibrium in Exoplanet Climates
Planetary atmospheric scientists routinely adapt Eddington's two-stream closure to model thermal greenhouse warming and anti-greenhouse hazes on terrestrial and gas-giant exoplanets, balancing incoming shortwave stellar flux against outgoing longwave infrared cooling across discrete pressure layers.
Radiative Acceleration and Eddington Luminosity Link
Closely allied with his radiative-transfer closure, Eddington derived the upper luminosity limit at which outward radiation pressure balances inward gravitational attraction on ionized hydrogen—demonstrating how moment equations unify photon transport with stellar structure and mass-loss stability in massive stars.
References
- Simonneau, E., & Crivellari, L. (1978). Radiative transfer in atmospheres with spherical symmetry—III. The Eddington approximation. Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer. https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-4073(78)90005-590005-5)
- Editorial (2020). Numerical Methods in Radiative Transfer. Radiative Transfer in Stellar and Planetary Atmospheres. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108583572.005
- Editorial (2020). The Physical Grounds of Radiative Transfer. Radiative Transfer in Stellar and Planetary Atmospheres. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108583572.003