Alcock–Paczyński Test
The Alcock–Paczyński test uses the fact that an object known to be statistically isotropic appears stretched or compressed along the line of sight if the wrong cosmology is assumed to convert redshifts and angles into distances, allowing galaxy clustering to constrain the product of the angular diameter distance and the Hubble parameter.
The Alcock–Paczyński Test is a geometric cosmological test proposed by Charles Alcock and Bohdan Paczyński in a 1979 paper in Nature. It exploits the fact that converting observed angular separations and redshift differences into physical distances requires an assumed cosmological model. If an object or statistical ensemble is known to be spherically symmetric, then any apparent departure from sphericity in the assumed coordinates reveals that the model is wrong. The distortion is largely independent of the intrinsic evolution of the objects, which makes the test attractive as a probe of the expansion history, and it has become a standard component of modern analyses of galaxy clustering and baryon acoustic oscillations.
Geometric Principle
Observers measure two quantities for each galaxy: the angular position on the sky and the redshift z. To obtain three-dimensional coordinates, a cosmological model is assumed. Transverse separations are computed from an angle Δθ using the comoving angular diameter distance, giving Δr⊥ = (1 + z) DA(z) Δθ, where DA is the angular diameter distance. Line-of-sight separations are computed from a redshift interval Δz, giving Δr∥ = (c / H(z)) Δz, where H(z) is the Hubble parameter and c the speed of light.
Consider a sphere of true comoving radius R at redshift z. Its angular extent is Δθ = R / [(1 + z) DA(z)], and its redshift extent is Δz = R H(z) / c. The ratio of redshift extent to angular extent, Δz / Δθ, is therefore proportional to the product (1 + z) DA(z) H(z) / c, which is a dimensionless quantity depending only on the true cosmology. A researcher who assumes a fiducial cosmology with distance functions DAfid and Hfid reconstructs an ellipsoid rather than a sphere unless the true and fiducial products coincide. The axis ratio of the reconstructed shape is the Alcock–Paczyński distortion parameter,
FAP(z) = (1 + z) DA(z) H(z) / c,
and the stretch factor along the line of sight relative to the transverse direction is FAPfid / FAP. Two warping parameters, often written α⊥ and α∥, rescale the transverse and radial coordinates, respectively, such that α⊥ = DA / DAfid and α∥ = Hfid / H.
The test is sensitive mainly to the geometry through the combination of distance and expansion rate. At low redshift, where DA is approximately c z / H0 and all models reduce to a linear Hubble law, FAP approaches a model-independent constant and the distortion vanishes. The sensitivity grows with redshift, as the curvature of the distance–redshift relation reflects the matter density and the properties of dark energy.
Original Proposal and the Search for Standard Spheres
Alcock and Paczyński originally proposed applying the idea to structures that might be spherical on average, with the best example being the voids and clusters of galaxies seen in redshift surveys. The challenge is that real structures are not spheres, and peculiar velocities, which add Doppler shifts to the cosmological redshift, further distort their shape along the line of sight. The difficulty is to find a population or statistic whose true shape is isotropic and whose evolution does not mimic the geometric distortion.
Subsequent proposals used the statistical isotropy of the universe in place of individual objects. On large scales, the clustering of galaxies should not depend on direction. The two-point correlation function ξ(r⊥, r∥) of a homogeneous and isotropic universe, expressed in true comoving coordinates, depends only on the total separation. Comparing the observed clustering in the transverse and line-of-sight directions therefore tests the assumed geometry. Ballinger, Peacock, and Heavens developed this approach in 1996, showing that the Alcock–Paczyński effect and the dynamical redshift-space distortions caused by coherent infall onto structures can be separated, because they have different dependence on the angle to the line of sight. They also demonstrated that the distortion can be used to place constraints on the matter density and the cosmological constant from a survey of realistic size.
Application to Baryon Acoustic Oscillations
The most successful application is to the baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) feature. Sound waves in the photon–baryon plasma before recombination left a preferred comoving separation in the distribution of matter, the sound horizon at the drag epoch, with a length of about 150 Mpc in the standard model. Its value is calibrated by the physics of the early universe and by the cosmic microwave background, including the damping scale set by silk damping. The feature appears as a localized bump in the correlation function, detected in luminous red galaxies by Eisenstein and collaborators in 2005, and as a series of damped oscillations in the power spectrum.
The BAO scale acts as a standard ruler. Measured in the transverse direction it gives DA(z) / rd, and measured along the line of sight it gives c / [H(z) rd], where rd is the sound horizon. A fitting procedure that allows separate dilation of the two directions, using multipoles of the correlation function or the power spectrum, measures α⊥ and α∥. This is an Alcock–Paczyński measurement in the sense that the ring of the acoustic scale, which would be circular in the true cosmology, appears as an ellipse when the wrong fiducial model is used. The BAO ring supplies the characteristic scale as well as the isotropy assumption, so the measurement constrains DA and H individually, not only their product.
An analysis that removes the information in the BAO scale and uses only the anisotropy of the broadband clustering isolates the pure Alcock–Paczyński signal, which constrains the product DA H but is independent of the sound horizon and thus of assumptions about early-universe physics.
Constraints from Galaxy Surveys
The Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (BOSS), part of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey III, measured the anisotropic clustering of over a million galaxies at redshifts 0.2 to 0.75. Its final data release analysis by Alam and collaborators in 2017 reported joint constraints on DA(z) rd,fid / rd and H(z) rd / rd,fid at several effective redshifts, with precision of a few percent. These results were consistent with the flat ΛCDM model and tightened limits on spatial curvature and the dark-energy equation of state.
The extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (eBOSS) extended the baseline to higher redshift by observing luminous red galaxies, emission-line galaxies, quasars, and Lyman-α forest absorption, reaching redshift 2.3 in the forest. The cosmological implications of the full eBOSS dataset, reported by Alam and collaborators in 2021, combined these samples and measured the expansion rate across more than ten billion years of cosmic history. The Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI), which began its main survey in 2021, observes tens of millions of galaxy and quasar redshifts and applies the same anisotropic BAO methodology with greater statistical power, offering a test of whether the dark-energy density evolves with time. The distance–expansion measurements in these programs also inform estimates of the expansion rate today, which is usually quoted as the Hubble constant.
Systematic Effects and Limitations
Three issues limit the test. Redshift-space distortions from peculiar velocities mimic an anisotropy of the same form, so a model of the velocity field must be fitted simultaneously with the geometric parameters. This coupling is the reason that the degeneracy between the growth rate of structure and the Alcock–Paczyński parameters is central to current analyses. Non-linear evolution and galaxy bias modify the shape of the correlation function and slightly shift the BAO peak, requiring reconstruction techniques that partly reverse the large-scale bulk flows. Finally, the fiducial cosmology adopted in the analysis introduces a model dependence, which is addressed by iterating or by quoting results in terms of ratios to the fiducial predictions.
The Alcock–Paczyński test links two independent routes to cosmic geometry. Standard-candle supernovae measure luminosity distance, whereas BAO and the Alcock–Paczyński effect measure transverse and radial angular scales at fixed comoving size, so their agreement provides a cross-check on the evolving content of the cosmos, including dark matter and dark energy.
References
- Alcock C, Paczyński B. An evolution free test for non-zero cosmological constant. Nature. 1979;281:358–359. https://doi.org/10.1038/281358a0
- Ballinger WE, Peacock JA, Heavens AF. Measuring the cosmological constant with redshift surveys. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 1996;282(3):877–888. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/282.3.877
- Eisenstein DJ, Zehavi I, Hogg DW, et al. Detection of the baryon acoustic peak in the large-scale correlation function of SDSS luminous red galaxies. The Astrophysical Journal. 2005;633(2):560–574. https://doi.org/10.1086/466512
- Alam S, Ata M, Bailey S, et al. The clustering of galaxies in the completed SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: cosmological analysis of the DR12 galaxy sample. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 2017;470(3):2617–2652. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stx721
- Alam S, Aubert M, Avila S, et al. Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: cosmological implications from two decades of spectroscopic surveys at the Apache Point Observatory. Physical Review D. 2021;103:083533. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.103.083533