โ† Wiki Index / Astronomy & Cosmology / Silk Damping
๐Ÿ”ญ Astronomy & Cosmology

Silk Damping

Silk damping is the suppression of small-scale anisotropies in the early universe caused by photons diffusing out of density perturbations in the tightly coupled baryon-photon plasma before recombination, producing the steep fall-off of the CMB power spectrum at high multipoles.

Silk Damping is the erasure of small-scale temperature and density fluctuations in the early universe by the diffusion of photons through the baryon-photon plasma, a process also called collisional damping or photon diffusion damping. First worked out by Joseph Silk in a 1968 paper in The Astrophysical Journal, it explains why the angular power spectrum of the cosmic microwave background falls steeply at multipoles above about โ„“ โ‰ˆ 1000 instead of continuing to display acoustic peaks of constant height. The characteristic damping scale is a precise function of the baryon density, the expansion rate, and the number of relativistic species, so measuring the damping tail constrains cosmological parameters independently of the peak positions.

The Tightly Coupled Plasma

Before recombination, at redshifts above about 1100, the universe contained free electrons, protons, helium nuclei, and photons. Photons scatter off free electrons by Thomson scattering, and electrons are bound to baryons by Coulomb interactions, so photons and baryons behave as a single fluid. Gravity compresses the fluid into potential wells, while photon pressure resists compression. The competition drives acoustic oscillations with sound speed

cs = c / โˆš(3(1 + R)), where R = 3ฯb / 4ฯฮณ,

ฯb and ฯฮณ being the baryon and photon energy densities. The same oscillations imprint baryon acoustic oscillations in matter and the peaks of the CMB spectrum. In the limit of infinite coupling, the oscillations would persist at all scales with no loss of amplitude.

Coupling is finite. The photon mean free path is ฮป = 1/(ne ฯƒT a), where ne is the free electron density, ฯƒT is the Thomson cross section, and a is the scale factor, and it grows as the universe expands and the plasma thins. A photon performs a random walk, scattering many times before the epoch of last scattering and slipping from hot regions into cold ones. This diffusion mixes photons of different temperatures and washes out fluctuations on scales smaller than the distance a photon can wander.

The Damping Scale

The diffusion distance traveled by a photon up to time t, in comoving units, defines the damping scale. In the Huโ€“Sugiyama treatment it is given by

kDโˆ’2 = โˆซ dฮท (1 / 6(1 + R) ne ฯƒT a) [R2 / (1 + R) + 16/15] ,

with ฮท conformal time and the bracket accounting for the combined effect of heat conduction and viscosity. The term 16/15 reflects photon viscosity from the quadrupole anisotropy of scattering, which includes the polarization dependence of Thomson scattering, while the R-dependent term reflects baryon-photon drag. Perturbations with wavenumbers k much larger than kD have amplitudes multiplied by a damping factor of the form

exp[โˆ’(k / kD)2],

evaluated at recombination. Silk originally derived the damping of adiabatic perturbations in a baryonic universe and identified a mass scale, the Silk mass, below which galaxies could not form from primordial adiabatic fluctuations. In the later cold dark matter picture, the Silk mass sets a scale in the baryon-photon fluid but not for dark matter, which does not suffer photon diffusion, so structure still forms on small scales.

The damping becomes strong as recombination proceeds, because the mean free path rises rapidly as free electrons vanish, so photons travel farther in the final moments. The finite thickness of the last scattering surface adds a second suppression of small-scale anisotropy, since averaging over the line-of-sight through the thick surface cancels contributions from short wavelengths. In practice, both processes combine, and their sum is usually modeled numerically with Boltzmann codes.

The CMB Damping Tail

The CMB angular power spectrum Cโ„“ shows a series of acoustic peaks, the first near โ„“ โ‰ˆ 220. The peaks decline in height and are eventually suppressed. At โ„“ โ‰ณ 1000 the spectrum falls approximately as a Gaussian envelope exp[โˆ’2(โ„“ / โ„“D)2] with โ„“D about 1300 to 1500 for the standard cosmology, so by โ„“ โ‰ˆ 2000 the primary anisotropy is a small fraction of its peak level. This is the damping tail.

Measuring the tail is challenging, since at these scales foregrounds and secondary effects take over. Emission from dusty galaxies and radio sources, the Sunyaevโ€“Zel'dovich effect, and gravitational lensing of the CMB add power that eventually exceeds the diminishing primary signal. Lensing smooths the peaks and transfers power into the tail, and the same nonlinear growth discussed in the context of the Ostrikerโ€“Vishniac effect produces secondary anisotropy at small angular scales. Experiments such as the Atacama Cosmology Telescope and the South Pole Telescope, together with the Planck satellite, have mapped the tail out to โ„“ of several thousand and separated primary from secondary contributions using multifrequency data.

Parameter Dependence

Silk damping depends on the physics that sets the diffusion length relative to the sound horizon.

Baryon density ฮฉbh2. More baryons increase electron density and shorten the mean free path, decreasing the diffusion distance and moving the damping to smaller scales. They also raise R, lowering the sound speed and changing the relative heights of odd and even peaks, so baryon density is determined from both peak ratios and the tail.

Expansion rate and matter density ฮฉmh2. The damping scale is an integral over time, so faster early expansion gives photons less time to diffuse and increases kD.

Effective number of neutrino species Neff. Additional relativistic species raise the radiation density and the expansion rate at fixed matter density, reducing the diffusion time, so the damping scale in angular terms shifts. The angular damping scale ฮธD = rD / DA is compared to the angular sound horizon ฮธs, and the ratio ฮธD/ฮธs is sensitive to Neff, which is how the damping tail constrains it. Free-streaming neutrinos also shift the phase of the acoustic peaks, offering a separate signature.

Primordial helium fraction Yp. Helium atoms bind electrons, so a higher helium abundance reduces the number of free electrons per baryon after helium recombination, lengthening the mean free path and increasing damping. The tail therefore constrains Yp independently of big-bang nucleosynthesis, offering a consistency test of the standard cosmic history.

Recombination history. The width of the last scattering surface affects the tail. Variations in the recombination model, such as extra energy injection from decaying particles, change the visibility function and the damping envelope.

Relation to Planck Constraints

The Planck 2018 analysis fit a six-parameter ฮ›CDM model to temperature and polarization spectra spanning โ„“ from 2 to about 2500. The damping tail contributes strong information on the angular damping scale ฮธD, which Planck measured with sub-percent precision, and from the combination with ฮธs obtained Neff = 2.92 with uncertainty near 0.19 from CMB alone, consistent with the standard value of 3.046. Planck's helium constraint from the CMB alone was Yp โ‰ˆ 0.24 with uncertainty of a few percent, consistent with nucleosynthesis predictions near 0.245. Polarization strengthens these results, since the polarization spectrum has a sharper damping tail and a distinct phase relative to temperature.

Silk damping is a cornerstone of the physical interpretation of the CMB. It marks the scale at which a fluid description of the early universe stops being adequate, since the photon distribution develops a quadrupole anisotropy and viscosity becomes relevant. It also provides a standard ruler beside the sound horizon and a probe of the radiation content and ionization history of the early universe. Related large-angle phenomena, such as the Sachsโ€“Wolfe effect, act on scales that remain unaffected by diffusion, so together the large-scale plateau, the acoustic peaks, and the damping tail span the full range of the primordial spectrum.

References

  1. Silk, J. (1968). Cosmic black-body radiation and galaxy formation. The Astrophysical Journal, 151, 459โ€“471. https://doi.org/10.1086/149449
  2. Hu, W., & Sugiyama, N. (1995). Anisotropies in the cosmic microwave background: An analytic approach. The Astrophysical Journal, 444, 489โ€“506. https://doi.org/10.1086/175624
  3. Hu, W., & Dodelson, S. (2002). Cosmic microwave background anisotropies. Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics, 40, 171โ€“216. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.astro.40.060401.093926
  4. Planck Collaboration (2020). Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters. Astronomy & Astrophysics, 641, A6. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201833910
๐Ÿงฌ Support Open Science
Explore interactive science games on LowKey Games or browse scientific apparel & accessories in the CRV Science Shop.
๐Ÿ’ก Spot an inaccuracy or have primary literature to expand this article?
Submit a citation or revision note using your shared CRV Science / LowKey Games profile ID.
Suggest Revision