← Wiki Index / Astronomy & Cosmology / Ostriker–Vishniac Effect
🔭 Astronomy & Cosmology

Ostriker–Vishniac Effect

The Ostriker–Vishniac effect is a second-order secondary anisotropy of the cosmic microwave background produced when photons Thomson-scatter off free electrons whose bulk velocity is modulated by the density fluctuations of an ionized universe, generating small-scale temperature fluctuations at multipoles of order a thousand and beyond.

The Ostriker–Vishniac Effect is a secondary anisotropy of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) arising from Thomson scattering by free electrons in a fully ionized intergalactic medium whose peculiar velocity and density both vary in space. It was predicted by Jeremiah P. Ostriker and Ethan T. Vishniac in 1986 (The Astrophysical Journal Letters), who showed that the coupling of density and velocity perturbations produces a net temperature fluctuation that does not cancel, and was given a rigorous linear-theory treatment by Vishniac in 1987 (The Astrophysical Journal). The effect is a second-order contribution to the kinetic Sunyaev–Zeldovich effect: because the first-order Doppler signal from bulk flows largely cancels along the line of sight on small scales, the leading surviving signal is proportional to the product of the electron density contrast and the line-of-sight velocity. The Ostriker–Vishniac signal peaks at angular scales of a few arcminutes and provides a window on the ionization history and growth of structure after recombination.

Physical Origin

After recombination at redshift z ≈ 1100, the primary CMB temperature fluctuations carry the imprint of acoustic oscillations in the photon-baryon plasma. If the universe stayed neutral, photons would travel freely to the observer. Reionization by the first stars and galaxies, completed by z ≈ 6, returned the intergalactic medium to an ionized state, leaving a Thomson optical depth of τ ≈ 0.05 to 0.06 as measured by the Planck satellite. Photons that scatter off moving free electrons are Doppler shifted: a scattering electron with line-of-sight velocity vr changes the photon temperature by ΔT/T = −(vr/c) per scattering, weighted by the scattering probability.

The first-order contribution to the observed temperature is

ΔT/T(n̂) = −∫ dτ (v · n̂)/c,

where the integral runs along the line of sight, τ is the optical depth, and v is the electron bulk velocity. In linear theory the velocity field is a gradient flow set by the density perturbation, so its Fourier modes point along the wavevector k. For a mode with wavevector nearly perpendicular to the line of sight, the velocity component along the line of sight is small, while for a mode with wavevector along the line of sight the contributions from successive wave crests and troughs cancel in the integral. Only modes with wavelength comparable to the radial extent of the scattering region contribute, and these have small projected effects. The net first-order effect on small angular scales is therefore heavily suppressed.

Second-Order Coupling

Ostriker and Vishniac realized that the cancellation is incomplete once one includes the fact that the scattering probability itself is proportional to the electron density ne = n̄e(1 + δ). Expanding the optical-depth weighting to second order gives an effective contribution

ΔT/T(n̂) = −∫ dτ̄ (δ v · n̂)/c,

where τ̄ is the mean optical depth and δ is the electron overdensity. A product of a density mode with wavevector k1 and a velocity mode with wavevector k2 produces a Fourier component at k1 + k2. If the two modes have comparable and large wavenumbers pointing in different directions, the sum has a large projected component on the sky while the radial oscillations are no longer self-canceling. The velocity has the form v(k) = i(aḟ/k) δ(k) k̂, linking its amplitude to the growth rate of linear perturbations, so the effect depends on both the matter power spectrum and the growth history. Because the amplitude depends on the product of two perturbations, it scales as the square of the density fluctuation amplitude, hence the description as second order.

Power Spectrum

In Vishniac's formulation, the angular power spectrum is obtained with the Limber approximation as an integral over conformal time of the matter power spectrum weighted by the visibility function and a mode-coupling kernel. The scaling can be summarized by three features:

  • The signal scales as Cℓ ∝ τ2 σ84 times a kernel dependent on reionization redshift, so it is sensitive to the clustering amplitude as well as to the ionization history.
  • The dimensionless quantity ℓ(ℓ + 1)Cℓ/2π grows roughly as ℓ at moderate ℓ and flattens to a broad maximum at ℓ of several thousand, where its amplitude is at the level of a fraction of a microkelvin squared (of order 10−2 to 10−1 μK2, depending on the reionization history).
  • The effect is blackbody: unlike the thermal Sunyaev–Zeldovich signal, its frequency spectrum is the derivative of the Planck function, so it cannot be separated from primary anisotropy by frequency alone, though primary anisotropies are damped by photon diffusion on these scales, making the secondary signal dominant above ℓ ≈ 3000 in the absence of other foregrounds.

The effect is larger for earlier, more complete reionization, because both the optical depth and the density contrast at the epoch of scattering increase.

Relation to Patchy Reionization and the Kinetic SZ Effect

The Ostriker–Vishniac calculation assumes a homogeneously ionized universe. Real reionization was inhomogeneous: ionized bubbles grew around early galaxies, producing a patchy electron distribution with an ionized fraction xe that varied across space. Fluctuations in xe multiply the velocity field in the same way as density fluctuations do, so patchy reionization generates an additional kSZ contribution with a similar angular structure, as shown by Gruzinov and Hu and Knox, Scoccimarro, and Dodelson (1998). Hu (2000) showed that the patchy term can dominate the Ostriker–Vishniac term and have a different dependence on the duration of reionization. Late-time kSZ from clusters and groups, with nonlinear density contrasts, adds a third piece. The observed small-scale kSZ power therefore combines a homogeneous Ostriker–Vishniac component, a reionization-epoch component, and a post-reionization component from collapsed structure, and separating them demands simulations. The relation of these distortions to other spectral signals is also discussed in the context of CMB spectral distortions.

Observational Constraints

Measuring the kSZ power spectrum is hard because of foregrounds: the thermal SZ effect from clusters, the cosmic infrared background from dusty galaxies, and radio point sources, all of which exceed the kSZ amplitude at 150 GHz on arcminute scales. The South Pole Telescope (SPT) and the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT) overcame this with multifrequency maps and foreground templates. George and colleagues (2015) used SPT data to place an upper limit on the kSZ power at ℓ = 3000 of roughly 5 μK2 and, combined with Planck optical depth, constrained the duration of reionization to Δz < 5.4 at 95 percent confidence. Later SPT and ACT analyses refined these bounds and reported evidence for a nonzero kSZ amplitude near 3 μK2 at ℓ = 3000, consistent with a late and extended reionization history. Because the homogeneous Ostriker–Vishniac component is far below this level, the measured signal is dominated by patchy reionization and late-time structure. Future experiments such as Simons Observatory and CMB-S4 aim to separate components using cross-correlation with galaxy surveys and the kSZ velocity reconstruction technique. The velocity field responsible is tied to the same growth of structure that shapes the baryon acoustic oscillations and the distribution of dark matter.

References

  1. Ostriker, J. P., & Vishniac, E. T. (1986). Generation of microwave background fluctuations from nonlinear perturbations at the era of galaxy formation. The Astrophysical Journal, 306, L51–L54. https://doi.org/10.1086/184704
  2. Vishniac, E. T. (1987). Reionization and small-scale fluctuations in the microwave background. The Astrophysical Journal, 322, 597–604. https://doi.org/10.1086/165755
  3. Hu, W. (2000). Reionization revisited: Secondary cosmic microwave background anisotropies and polarization. The Astrophysical Journal, 529(1), 12–25. https://doi.org/10.1086/308279
  4. George, E. M., et al. (2015). A measurement of secondary cosmic microwave background anisotropies from the 2500-square-degree SPT-SZ survey. The Astrophysical Journal, 799(2), 177. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/799/2/177
🧬 Support Open Science
Explore interactive science games on LowKey Games or browse scientific apparel & accessories in the CRV Science Shop.
💡 Spot an inaccuracy or have primary literature to expand this article?
Submit a citation or revision note using your shared CRV Science / LowKey Games profile ID.
Suggest Revision