Molar-Tooth Structure
Molar-tooth structure is an enigmatic Precambrian carbonate sedimentary fabric consisting of crumpled, early-cemented microspar calcite ribbons and spheroids that formed exclusively during the Paleoproterozoic to middle Neoproterozoic eras.
Molar-tooth structure (often abbreviated MTS or molar-tooth carbonate) is a distinctive, time-restricted synsedimentary carbonate fabric consisting of vertical, oblique, horizontal, and ptygmatically folded cracks and voids filled with uniform, equant microcrystalline calcite (microspar) embedded within fine-grained argillaceous limestone or dolomite. First described and named by British geologist Hilary Bauerman in 1885 during his reconnaissance of the Mesoproterozoic Belt Supergroup along the 49th parallel of North America, the structure takes its name from the corrugated, winding ridges left on weathered outcrop surfaces, which closely resemble the occlusal enamel folds on the grinding surface of an elephant's molar tooth.
Stratigraphic Distribution and the ~750 Ma Disappearance
Molar-tooth structure is one of the primary sedimentological hallmarks of Precambrian marine platform stratigraphy. Although rare examples appear in late Paleoproterozoic successions (~1,900โ1,700 Ma), molar-tooth carbonates reached peak global abundance across shallow subtidal to intertidal ramp environments throughout the Mesoproterozoic (1,600โ1,000 Ma) and early Tonian (1,000โ750 Ma) periodsโa temporal interval often termed the "Boring Billion."
Classic molar-tooth-bearing formations include the Helena and Wallace formations of the Belt-Purcell Supergroup (Montana, Idaho, and British Columbia), the Victor Bay Formation (Baffin Island), the Gaoyuzhuang and Wumishan formations (North China Craton), the Sukhaya Tunguska Formation (Siberia), and the Bambuรญ and Vazante groups (South America). Remarkably, molar-tooth structures vanished abruptly from the global rock record near 750โ720 Ma, immediately prior to the Sturtian Cryogenian glaciation, and never reappeared in Phanerozoic marine carbonates despite the widespread persistence of shallow lime-mud platforms.
| Petrographic / Stratigraphic Attribute | Molar-Tooth Microspar Fill | Host Carbonate Matrix | Phanerozoic Diagenetic Spar Veins |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crystal Size and Habit | Uniform 5โ15 ฮผm equant, polygonal to subhedral rhombic microspar | <4 ฮผm micrite or dolomicrite mixed with 5%โ25% clay and silt | Coarse, drusy, blocky, or fibrous sparite (50โ2,000 ฮผm) widening inward |
| Mineralogy & Cathodoluminescence | Stoichiometric low-Mg calcite; typically non-luminescent cores with thin zoned rims | Frequently dolomitized during burial while microspar ribbons remain pure CaCO3 | Variable Fe/Mn-bearing calcite or saddle dolomite with bright zonation |
| Timing of Lithification | Synsedimentary (tens of centimeters below seafloor, prior to host mud compaction) | Compacted 40%โ70% around rigid microspar ribbons during burial | Post-lithification brittle tectonic fracturing of hardened rock |
| Intraclast Reworking | Frequently eroded by storm waves into brittle, angular molar-tooth intraclast breccias | Reworked as soft mud chips or suspension plume sediment | Never reworked into contemporaneous storm lag beds |
Petrography and Early Diagenetic Lithification
Under petrographic and scanning electron microscopy, molar-tooth ribbons exhibit an extraordinarily uniform crystal fabric that distinguishes them from both ordinary carbonate mud (micrite) and post-burial tectonic calcite veins.
Equant Microspar Fabric
Whereas typical marine cavity-filling cements precipitate as competitive, inward-coarsening fibrous aragonite needles or blocky drusy sparite crystals (50 to >1,000 ฮผm across), molar-tooth voids are filled entirely from wall to center by homogeneous, tightly interlocking 5โ15 ฮผm equant polygonal crystals of low-magnesium calcite. Individual microspar crystals commonly preserve a 2โ5 ฮผm spherical or rhombic core surrounded by a syntaxial overgrowth rim, indicating simultaneous, high-density nucleation throughout the fluid-filled void followed by rapid crystal growth until impingement.
Pre-Compactional Rigidity and Ptygmatic Folding
Two field criteria prove that molar-tooth microspar precipitated and lithified during earliest diagenesis, within a few centimeters to decimeters of the sedimentโwater interface:
- Differential Compaction Deformation: Originally vertical molar-tooth ribbons were rigid solid calcite walls while the surrounding water-saturated lime mud remained soft and plastic. As overburden accumulated and the host mud compacted by 40% to 70%, the rigid vertical microspar sheets buckled, telescoped, and fractured into sinusoidal ptygmatic folds and offset segments while host sedimentary laminae draped smoothly around them.
- Synsedimentary Storm Reworking: High-energy storm beds (tempestites) interbedded with molar-tooth mudstones routinely contain lag pavements of sharp, angular molar-tooth intraclastsโbroken plates of already-lithified microspar eroded from the seafloor while the surrounding unlithified mud was winnowed away into suspension.
Competing Formation Models
Explaining how open cracks and spheroidal voids formed in soupy, unlithified subtidal mud and immediately cemented with uniform microspar requires pairing a void-generation mechanism with a rapid CaCO3 precipitation trigger.
Biogenic Gas Expansion Model
Proposed by Horace G. Smith (1968) and expanded by Furniss, Rittel, and Winston (1998), the gas-expansion hypothesis links molar-tooth genesis to microbial decay beneath cohesive benthic stromatolite and cyanobacterial mats. As heterotrophic sulfate-reducing and methanogenic bacteria oxidized buried organic matter within the shallow sediment column, they generated biogenic gasesโprimarily hydrogen sulfide (H2S), carbon dioxide (CO2), and methane (CH4). Trapped beneath impermeable surface microbial mats or cohesive clay-rich lime muds, rising gas bubbles coalesced into spherical vesicles ("blobs") that ruptured upward into vertical planar sheet cracks as buoyancy overcame the low tensile strength of the mud.
Seismic Liquefaction and Synsedimentary Fracturing
An alternative physical model, developed by Brian R. Pratt (1998, 2001) and Noel P. James, attributes void opening to earthquake-induced cyclic shear stresses acting on thixotropic, clay-bearing lime muds. Seismic shaking triggered dewatering, shrinkage, and hydrofracturing along horizontal bedding planes and vertical tension gashes. Because pore waters in Mesoproterozoic seas lacked skeletal calcifiers and maintained extreme carbonate alkalinity and CaCO3 supersaturation (ฮฉ > 10โ20), upward injection of pore fluids or sudden CO2 degassing into newly opened cracks triggered instantaneous nucleation of millions of suspended calcite seed crystals per cubic centimeter, rapidly cementing the cracks as microspar before the mud walls could collapse.
Why Molar-Tooth Structures Vanished After 750 Ma
The abrupt extinction of molar-tooth fabrics near the TonianโCryogenian boundary reflects a permanent transition in both global ocean chemistry and benthic ecology:
- Decline in Seawater Carbonate Supersaturation: Rising late Neoproterozoic marine sulfate (SO42โ) concentrations and shifting Mg:Ca ratios, combined with the subsequent EdiacaranโCambrian evolution of biomineralizing animals, drew down background seawater alkalinity so pore waters could no longer flash-precipitate microspar inside open mud cracks before wall collapse.
- Agronomic Revolution and Bioturbation: Once early motile metazoans and eukaryotic mat-grazers began burrowing through shallow marine muds, they destroyed impermeable surface microbial seals, homogenized sediment shear strength, and irrigated pore waters, preventing both pressurized gas trapping and cohesive brittle crack preservation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are molar-tooth structures trace fossils left by Precambrian animals?
No. Although early geologists occasionally mistook the sinuous ribbons for burrows or algal body fossils, molar-tooth structures are entirely abiotic/organomineralic sedimentary structures formed by gas or seismic cracking of cohesive lime mud followed by rapid inorganic or microbially induced calcite microspar precipitation, predating true bilaterian burrowing animals by nearly a billion years.
Why do molar-tooth ribbons resist dolomitization when the surrounding rock turns to dolomite?
During burial diagenesis, fine-grained <4 ฮผm host micrite has high microporosity, high reactive surface area, and abundant clay seams that channel magnesium-rich dolomitizing fluids. By contrast, the 5โ15 ฮผm molar-tooth microspar was cemented into a tight, non-porous mosaic of low-magnesium calcite on the seafloor, rendering the ribbons virtually impermeable to later dolomitizing brines.
References
- Bauerman, H. (1885). "Report on the Geology of the Country Near the Forty-Ninth Parallel of North Latitude West of the Rocky Mountains." Geological Survey of Canada, Report of Progress, 1882โ1884(B), 1โ42.
- Furniss, G., Rittel, J. F., & Winston, D. (1998). "Gas Bubble and Expansion Crack Origin of 'Molar-Tooth' Calcite Structures in the Middle Proterozoic Belt Supergroup, Western Montana." Journal of Sedimentary Research, 68(1), 104โ114. https://doi.org/10.2110/jsr.68.104
- Pratt, B. R. (1998). "Molar-Tooth Structure in Proterozoic Carbonate Rocks: Origin from Synsedimentary Dewatering and Infill by Microspar." Geological Society of America Bulletin, 110(8), 1028โ1045. https://doi.org/10.1130/0016-7606(1998)110<1028:MTSIPC>2.3.CO;2110%3C1028:MTSIPC%3E2.3.CO;2)
- Shields, G. A. (2002). "'Molar-Tooth Microspar': A Chemical Explanation for the Disappearance of a Major Proterozoic Carbonate Fabric." Terra Nova, 14(2), 108โ113. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-3121.2002.00396.x
- Hodgskiss, M. S. W., Kunzmann, M., Poirier, A., & Halverson, G. P. (2018). "The Role of Microbial Mats and Seawater Chemistry in the Formation of Molar-Tooth Structure." Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 482, 322โ333.