Tully–Fisher Galaxy Relation
The Tully–Fisher relation is an empirical scaling relationship in extragalactic astronomy connecting the total luminosity or baryonic mass of a spiral galaxy to its asymptotic rotational velocity.
The Tully–Fisher relation, discovered in 1977 by astronomers R. Brent Tully and J. Richard Fisher, is an empirical scaling relationship connecting the intrinsic luminosity (or total baryonic mass) of a disk galaxy to its maximum internal rotational velocity or spectral line width. Originating as a standard candle technique to estimate extragalactic distances and determine the Hubble constant (H0), the relationship reflects a fundamental physical coupling between the total luminous matter in a spiral galaxy and the depth of its dark matter gravitational potential well.
As an empirical law spanning five orders of magnitude in mass, the Tully–Fisher relation provides essential observational constraints on galaxy formation physics, cold dark matter (CDM) halo assembly, and alternative gravitational paradigms such as Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND).
Theoretical Foundations and Historical Context
Measuring distances across cosmological scales requires identifying physical properties that correlate tightly with intrinsic luminosity, independent of distance from Earth. Prior to the late 1970s, establishing the extragalactic distance scale beyond the Local Group was hampered by large observational uncertainties; the formulation of a robust relationship grounded in the rotational dynamics of neutral hydrogen gas provided a decisive secondary distance indicator that opened the wider universe to systematic distance mapping.
The 21-Centimeter Line Width Diagnostic
Tully and Fisher recognized that neutral atomic hydrogen (H I) gas extends far into the outer, rotationally dominated disks of spiral galaxies, well beyond the bright optical starlight. By observing the forbidden 21-centimeter hyperfine transition line using single-dish radio telescopes, astronomers measure the global velocity profile of the galaxy:
- The approaching side of the rotating disk is Doppler-shifted toward higher frequencies (blueshifted).
- The receding side is Doppler-shifted toward lower frequencies (redshifted).
The resulting radio emission spectrum displays a characteristic "two-horned" profile whose full width at 20% or 50% of peak intensity (W20 or W50) reflects twice the projected line-of-sight rotational velocity:
W = 2 Vrot sin i
where i is the inclination angle of the galaxy's disk relative to the observer's line of sight (i = 0° for face-on; i = 90° for edge-on). Once corrected for inclination and turbulent velocity dispersion, the intrinsic maximum circular velocity Vmax is obtained.
Mathematical Derivation from Centrifugal Equilibrium
The physical basis of the scaling relation can be motivated by combining centrifugal orbital equilibrium with simple disk structure models. For a test particle orbiting at radius R in a disk with total dynamical mass M:
V² = G M / R
Assuming that galaxies have roughly constant surface brightness I0 (Freeman's law, where L ∝ I0 R²) and a constant mass-to-light ratio (M / L = Υ):
M = Υ L
R ∝ √(L / I0)
Substituting these expressions into the velocity equation:
V² ∝ G (Υ L) / √(L / I0) = G Υ √(I0) √L
Squaring both sides yields the classical theoretical Tully–Fisher scaling:
L ∝ V⁴
Despite the simplicity of this derivation—which ignores the dominant mass of non-luminous dark matter halos—empirical observations across thousands of galaxies consistently confirm a power-law exponent near 4.
The Baryonic Tully–Fisher Relation (BTFR)
While the optical relation exhibits significant scatter among gas-rich dwarf galaxies, accounting for all baryonic components unifies the scaling law into an exceptionally tight physical relation. Early investigations demonstrated that optical luminosities alone mischaracterize low-mass systems whose gas mass exceeds their stellar mass, requiring an explicit synthesis of neutral gas and stars to evaluate true rotational dynamics across cosmic time.
The Gas-Rich Deficit and Stacy McGaugh's Synthesis
In standard optical wavebands (such as B or V band), low-mass dwarf irregular galaxies systematically fall below the Tully–Fisher relation defined by massive, luminous spirals. In 2000, Stacy S. McGaugh and colleagues demonstrated that this divergence is an artifact of neglecting cold interstellar gas.
In luminous spiral galaxies like the Milky Way or Andromeda, stars represent roughly 80% to 90% of the total baryonic matter. In dwarf irregular galaxies, however, neutral and molecular gas (H I and H2) dominates, comprising up to 90% of the total baryonic mass.
Formulation of the BTFR
When astronomers define the total baryonic mass Mbaryon as the sum of stellar mass M* and cold gas mass Mgas:
Mbaryon = M* + Mgas = Υ* L + 1.33 MHI
(where the factor of 1.33 accounts for primordial cosmic helium), the relation snaps into a single, continuous power law spanning five orders of magnitude, from giant spirals down to tiny dwarf irregulars with Vrot ≈ 20 km/s:
Mbaryon = A (Vflat)4.0 ± 0.1
High-precision investigations using the Spitzer Photometry and Accurate Rotation Curves (SPARC) database by Federico Lelli, Stacy McGaugh, and James Schombert (2016) demonstrated that the intrinsic scatter of the BTFR is remarkably small (<0.1 dex), with no observable residual dependence on galaxy size, surface brightness, or gas fraction.
Cosmological Implications and Gravitational Debates
The tightness and universality of the Tully–Fisher relation pose fundamental questions for both standard cold dark matter cosmology and modified gravity theories. Cosmological hydrodynamical simulations must explain how complex feedback processes converge on a single universal power law, while alternative theories view this empirical relation as primary evidence for non-Newtonian gravitational dynamics at low accelerations.
The Dark Matter Fine-Tuning Challenge
In the standard Lambda-Cold Dark Matter (ΛCDM) cosmological model, the circular velocity in the outer disk is set by the gravitational potential of the dark matter halo, while the baryonic mass represents only a fraction of the total matter.
Because baryonic processes—such as gas cooling, star formation efficiency, supernova feedback, and active galactic nucleus (AGN) winds—are stochastic and non-linear, galaxy formation simulations typically struggle to reproduce a power law with consistently constant slope and near-zero scatter across all galaxy masses without fine-tuning feedback parameters.
Success of MOND Phenomenology
The Tully–Fisher relation is a cornerstone of Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND), formulated by Mordehai Milgrom in 1983. In the deep MOND regime where gravitational acceleration falls below a essential threshold a0 ≈ 1.2 × 10-10 m/s²:
a² / a0 = G Mbaryon / R²
Since a = V⁴ / R² for circular orbits, setting the two equal yields:
Vflat⁴ = G a0 Mbaryon
This equation matches the observed Baryonic Tully–Fisher Relation precisely, with the normalization constant directly specifying Milgrom's acceleration constant a0 without invoking unobserved dark matter particles.
Extragalactic Scaling Relations Comparison
| Relation | Galaxy Morphology | Kinematic Metric | Photometric / Mass Metric | Primary Use |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tully–Fisher (Optical) | Spiral / Disk galaxies | 21-cm H I line width (W) | Optical luminosity (LB, LI) | Distance scale, H0 |
| Baryonic Tully–Fisher | Spirals & Dwarf Irregulars | Flat rotation velocity (Vflat) | Total baryonic mass (M* + Mgas) | Halo physics, MOND tests |
| Faber–Jackson | Elliptical galaxies | Central velocity dispersion (σ) | Total optical luminosity (L) | Early-type distance scale |
| Fundamental Plane | Elliptical galaxies | Velocity dispersion (σ), size (Re) | Mean surface brightness (Ie) | High-precision elliptical distance |
References
- Aaronson, M., Huchra, J., & Mould, J. (1979). "The infrared luminosity/H I velocity-width relation and its application to the distance scale." The Astrophysical Journal, 229, 1–14. https://doi.org/10.1086/156923
- McGaugh, S. S., Schombert, J. M., Bothun, G. D., & de Blok, W. J. G. (2000). "The baryonic Tully-Fisher relation." The Astrophysical Journal, 533(2), L99–L102. https://doi.org/10.1086/312628
- Lelli, F., McGaugh, S. S., & Schombert, J. M. (2016). "The small scatter of the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation." The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 816(1), L14. https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8205/816/1/L14
- Aaronson, M., Mould, J., & Huchra, J. (1980). "A distance scale from the infrared magnitude/H I velocity-width relation. I - The calibration." The Astrophysical Journal, 237, 655–665. https://doi.org/10.1086/157912