← Wiki Index / Geology & Paleontology / Cone-in-Cone Structures
🪨 Geology & Paleontology

Cone-in-Cone Structures

Cone-in-cone structures are secondary diagenetic sedimentary features consisting of nested arrays of concentric fibrous calcite cones separated by corrugated, clay-lined shear laminae within organic-rich shales and marls.

Cone-in-cone structures are distinctive secondary diagenetic structures found in organic-rich calcareous shales, marls, and carbonate concretions, consisting of nested, interpenetrating circular cones of fibrous calcite (CaCO3) (or rarely siderite, gypsum, or barite) arranged with their central axes perpendicular to bedding and their apices pointing either downward, upward, or mutually inward toward a central bedding plane or septarian concretion core. First described in 1793 by the Scottish Enlightenment natural historian David Ure as "conical striated limestone" (Tutenmergel or Nagelkalk in German geological literature) and investigated petrographically by H. C. Sorby (1860), W. A. Tarr (1932), and modern cathodoluminescence/isotopic geochemists, individual cones measure 0.5 to 15 cm in height, exhibit remarkably consistent apical angles of 20° to 60° (most commonly 30°–45°), and are separated from concentric inner and outer cones by corrugated, stepped annular rings of dark clay residue. Often mistaken by amateurs for fossilized tree bark, coral colonies, or vertebrate teeth, cone-in-cone layers record displacive fibrous crystal growth (force of crystallization) coupled with conical shear failure under elevated pore-fluid pressure during early-to-intermediate burial diagenesis.

Morphology, Crystallography, and Stepped Clay Rings

Nested Conical Geometry and Fibrous Calcite Habit

In outcrop and slabbed cross-section, cone-in-cone calcite typically forms tabular bed-parallel crusts (1 to 20 cm thick) or concentric outer rinds enveloping flattened ellipsoidal carbonate concretions hosted within dark, fine-grained mudrocks deposited below the settling velocity threshold of the Hjulström curve. Each macroscopic cone is actually a composite stack of tens of smaller, nested conical cups (hence "cone-in-cone"), exhibiting three diagnostic microstructural elements:

  1. Plumose Fibrous Calcite Bundles: Thin-section petrography under crossed polarizers reveals that the body of each cone is composed of tightly packed, slightly radiating sub-vertical fibers of low-magnesium calcite. Crucially, the crystallographic c-axes (optic axes) of the calcite fibers are oriented parallel or sub-parallel to the vertical cone axis (perpendicular to bedding) rather than parallel to the inclined conical walls (which dip at 15°–30° relative to the c-axis).
  2. Apical Angles Matching Mohr–Coulomb Conjugate Shear Angles: Across Paleozoic, Mesozoic, and Cenozoic shales worldwide, the apical angle (2θ) of calcite cone-in-cone clusters tightly between 30° and 50° (with higher angles of 60°–90° restricted to recrystallization-modified zones). This geometry corresponds to the theoretical Mohr–Coulomb conjugate shear fracture angle (2θ = 90° − φ ≈ 45°–60°) developed under uniaxial vertical effective compressive stress (σ1 vertical, σ2 = σ3 horizontal).
  3. Corrugated Clay-Rich Annular Steps ("Gilsonite/Illite Rings"): The sloping outer surface of every cone—and the interface between nested inner and outer cones—is coated by a thin film of insoluble host-rock clay (illite/smectite) and organic matter sculpted into horizontal, stair-step annular corrugations (rings) that resemble tiny fault-plane slickensides and stylolitic pressure-solution seams.
FeatureDiagnostic Observation in Cone-in-Cone CalciteExcluded Alternative HypothesisFavored Diagenetic Mechanism
Calcite Fiber c-AxisSub-vertical (perpendicular to bedding; 15°–25° oblique to cone wall)Open-cavity drusy vug infilling (where fibers grow normal to walls)Displacive vertical fibrous growth pushing host mud apart
Apical Angle (2θ)20°–50° (Mode ≈ 35°–45°, axis normal to bedding)Random biogenic shell or algal stromatolite morphologyMohr–Coulomb conical shear planes under vertical overburden σ1
Corrugated Clay FilmsStepped concentric rings of displaced host shale inside conesPrimary depositional current ripples or convolute laminationIncremental shear displacement + pressure dissolution of clay matrix
Stable Isotopes (δ13C, δ18O)δ13C ≈ −15‰ to −35‰ or +5‰ to +15‰; δ18O ≈ −4‰ to −12‰Normal marine seafloor water (δ13C ≈ 0‰, δ18O ≈ 0‰)Anaerobic sulfate reduction / methanogenesis at shallow-to-moderate burial

Diagenetic Origin: Displacive Crystallization and Overpressure

Competing Historical Hypotheses

Over two centuries of geological debate, four major hypotheses were proposed to explain cone-in-cone formation:

  1. Gas-Bubble Escape Hypothesis: Escaping marsh gas bubbles rising through soft mud created conical vents later filled by calcite—refuted because cone apices normally point into the bed or toward concretion centers rather than upward toward the seafloor, unlike true fluid-escape dish structures or density-driven flame structures.
  2. Aragonite-to-Calcite Polymorphic Inversion Volume Expansion: Fibrous aragonite inverted to calcite with an ~8.3% molar volume expansion that fractured the layer into shear cones—challenged because trace-element (low Sr2+ < 300 ppm) and cathode-luminescence textures show primary low-Mg calcite precipitation without aragonite pseudomorphs.
  3. Pure Tectonic/Overburden Brittle Crushing of Fibrous Veins (Tarr, 1932): Pre-existing fibrous beef-calcite veins were crushed by later overburden compaction along conical shear fractures.
  4. ** Coupled Displacive Fibrous Crystal Growth and Pore-Fluid Overpressure (Franks, 1969; Selles-Martinez, 1994; Cobbold et al., 2013):** The modern consensus model integrates force of crystallization (displacive growth) with hydraulic overpressure during shallow-to-intermediate burial (depths of tens to a few hundred meters).

Microbial Alkalinity Engines and Force of Crystallization

As organic-rich marine or lacustrine muds undergo burial beneath the oxic zone (where surface electrogenic cable bacteria operate), anaerobic microbial bacterial sulfate reduction (BSR: 2 CH2O + SO42− → 2 HCO3− + H2S) and deeper methanogenesis generate high pore-water bicarbonate alkalinity and carbonate supersaturation, recorded by strongly depleted or fractionated carbon isotope signatures (δ13CVPDB ≈ −15‰ to −35‰ in the BSR zone, or +5‰ to +15‰ in the methanogenic zone). Simultaneously, disequilibrium compaction of low-permeability shale traps pore fluids until pore-fluid pressure (Pf) approaches lithostatic vertical stress (σv), reducing the vertical effective stress (σ'v = σv − Pf ≈ 0) to the point where horizontal bedding planes part by hydraulic jacking.

Within these incipient horizontal fractures or concretion margins, supersaturated pore water nucleates sub-vertical fibrous calcite ("beef" veins) whose linear crystallization pressure (up to 10–40 MPa) actively jacks the soft, plastic host mud apart vertically. Because radial expansion of diverging crystal fiber bundles against the plastic clay matrix generates combined vertical compression and lateral wedging tension, the growing fibrous aggregate periodically slips along conical Mohr–Coulomb shear surfaces (apical angle 30°–50°), trapping thin films of displaced host shale along the conical slip planes and offsetting them into corrugated stair-steps.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are cone-in-cone structures sometimes mistaken for plant or vertebrate fossils?

When weathered out of soft shale slopes, individual calcite cones (2–10 cm long) detach along their clay-lined shear surfaces as dark gray, conical "horn-shaped" stones ringed by regular transverse ribs and longitudinal fibrous striations. To casual collectors, these ribbed cones closely resemble horn corals (rugose corals), calamite horsetail stems, petrified pine cones, or conical reptile teeth, earning them the historical folk name Nagelkalk ("nail limestone"). A drop of dilute hydrochloric acid (confirming fibrous calcite without internal septa, tabulae, or cellular vascular canals) and observation of nested smaller cones inside the broken base readily distinguish cone-in-cone from any biological fossil.

How do "beef" fibrous calcite veins relate to cone-in-cone beds in hydrocarbon source rocks?

Horizontal veins of parallel fibrous calcite—known since 19th-century Dorset quarrymen in the Wessex Basin of southern England as "beef" due to their resemblance to fibrous cuts of meat—frequently grade laterally and vertically into cone-in-cone layers within the same organic-rich black shales (such as the Jurassic Charmouth/Kimmeridge clays, Devonian Marcellus Shale, and Cretaceous Pierre Shale). Both form during pore-fluid overpressure events when Pf ≈ σv; pure parallel "beef" develops in clean, homogeneous fractures where crystal fibers grow straight across a fluid-filled opening, whereas cone-in-cone develops when the fibers grow displacively inside a clay-rich mud matrix whose cohesive resistance triggers conical shear partitioning.

References

  1. Tarr, W. A. (1932). "Cone-in-cone." In W. H. Twenhofel (Ed.), Treatise on Sedimentation (2nd ed., pp. 716–733). Williams & Wilkins.
  2. Franks, P. C. (1969). "Nature, origin, and significance of cone-in-cone structures in the Kiowa Formation (Early Cretaceous), north-central Kansas." Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, 39(4), 1438–1454. https://doi.org/10.1306/74D71E51-2B21-11D7-8648000102C1865D
  3. Selles-Martinez, J. (1994). "New insights in the origin of cone-in-cone structures." Carbonates and Evaporites, 9(2), 172–186. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03175229
  4. Cobbold, P. R., Zanella, A., Rodrigues, N., & Løseth, H. (2013). "Bedding-parallel fibrous veins (beef and cone-in-cone): Worldwide occurrence and possible significance in terms of fluid overpressure, hydrocarbon generation and mineralization." Marine and Petroleum Geology, 43, 1–20. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2013.01.010
🧬 Support Open Science
Explore interactive science games on LowKey Games or browse scientific apparel & accessories in the CRV Science Shop.
💡 Spot an inaccuracy or have primary literature to expand this article?
Submit a citation or revision note using your shared CRV Science / LowKey Games profile ID.
Suggest Revision