โ† Wiki Index / Geology & Paleontology / Dish Structure
๐Ÿชจ Geology & Paleontology

Dish Structure

Dish structure is a water-escape soft-sediment deformation feature in rapidly deposited sandy turbidites and fluidized sediment flows, consisting of concave-upward, clay-enriched dark laminae separated by vertical fluid-escape pillars.

Dish structure (often paired with vertical pillar structures as dish-and-pillar structures) is a synsedimentary water-escape (fluidization) sedimentary structure consisting of sub-horizontal arrays of thin, dark, clay- or organic-enriched concave-upward laminations ("dishes") ranging from 2 to 50 cm in width and 0.5 to 5 cm in vertical relief, separated at their upturned rims by vertical or steeply inclined homogenized sand pipes termed pillars. First named and documented in 1967 by P. H. Stauffer in Lower Tertiary thick-bedded deep-marine sandstones of the Santa Ynez Mountains, California, and analyzed experimentally and petrographically by Donald R. Lowe and R. D. LoPiccolo (1974), dish structures are a diagnostic facies hallmark of high-density sandy turbidite deposits, submarine canyon grain flows, and liquefied delta-front sheet sands. Rather than representing primary current ripples or desiccation cracks, dish structures record the retarded upward seepage of overpressured pore water baffled beneath semi-permeable clay-rich laminae during the rapid consolidation of a fluidized sand bed.

Morphology and Vertical Zoning Within Sandstone Beds

Geometry of Individual Dishes and Intervening Pillars

In vertical outcrop faces cut perpendicular to bedding, dish structures appear as stacked, overlapping saucer- or bowl-shaped dark lines (each 0.2 to 2.0 mm thick) embedded within otherwise structureless or faintly laminated fine-to-coarse sandstone. In horizontal plan view on bedding surfaces, the dishes are circular, elliptical, or polygonal in outline. Petrographic examination shows that each dark dish lamina is enriched in fine-grained phyllosilicate clay flakes, mica platelets, and organic detritus relative to the clean quartz sand directly above and below the dish.

At the lateral edges of each dish, the dark clay lamina curls sharply upwardโ€”often becoming vertical or slightly involutedโ€”where it is truncated by a pillar structure: a vertical column or sheet (0.5 to 5 cm wide and 2 to 30 cm tall) of structureless, clean, unlaminated quartz sand through which escaping pore fluid broke upward across the clay baffle.

Systematic Upward Decrease in Dish Width and Increase in Concavity

Within a single thick-bedded high-density turbidite or fluidized sediment flow (0.5 to 5 m thick), dish structures exhibit a systematic vertical progression from base to top documented by Stauffer (1967) and Lowe & LoPiccolo (1974):

  1. Lower Zone (Base of Bed): Dishes are broad, wide (15 to 50 cm across), and nearly flat with gently upturned margins, grading downward into structureless or parallel-laminated sand lying above basal load casts and flame structures.
  2. Middle Zone: Dishes become progressively narrower (5 to 15 cm wide), more closely spaced vertically, and deeply concave-upward (hemispherical or soup-bowl shaped), accompanied by abundant vertical fluid-escape pillars piercing between dish rims.
  3. Upper Zone (Top of Bed): Deeply curved small dishes (2 to 5 cm wide) grade upward into strongly contorted convolute lamination, small sand volcanoes at the bed top, or normal Bouma Tcโ€“e ripple and mudstone divisions before burial diagenesis generates secondary carbonate features such as cone-in-cone structures.
Stratigraphic Horizon Within BedTypical Dish Width (W, cm)Dish Radius of Curvature (Concavity)Associated Deformation FeaturesHydrodynamic Regime During Consolidation
Lower Bed Zone15โ€“50 cm (Broad, flat-bottomed)Low concavity (Shallow trays)Planar lamination, basal load casts & flame structuresEarly compaction; modest upward pore-water flux from basal sand
Middle Bed Zone5โ€“15 cm (Intermediate width)Moderate-to-high concavity (Saucer/bowl shapes)Prominent vertical fluid-escape pillars at dish edgesCumulative upward water flux from consolidating underlying sand column
Upper Bed Zone2โ€“6 cm (Narrow, tightly curved)High concavity (Deep cups / Teacups)Convolute lamination, ball-and-pillow structures, sand volcanoesMaximum cumulative pore-fluid flux & vertical breakthrough velocity

Hydrodynamic Mechanism: Pore-Fluid Escape and Clay Baffling

Why Dishes Are Not Primary Current Ripples or Desiccation Mudcracks

When Stauffer (1967) first described dish structures in California flysch deposits, several geologists hypothesized that dishes were either cross-laminations of migrating antidunes, load-deformed starved ripples, or subaerial mud curls reworked by currents. In 1974, Donald R. Lowe and R. D. LoPiccolo refuted primary current and subaerial hypotheses through three petrographic observations:

  1. Dish laminae cut across primary grain-size grading and faintly preserved planar traction laminations, proving that dishes form post-depositionally during early bed consolidation.
  2. Unlike mudcracks (which form in cohesive clay beds exposed to air and fill from above with sand), dishes occur wholly inside thick subaqueous deep-marine sandstone beds that never experienced subaerial exposure.
  3. The clay platelets inside each dish are plastered against the underside of the sand layer as a filtration cake rather than settled from suspension according to Stokes' law on the Hjulstrรถm curve.

The Loweโ€“LoPiccolo Semi-Permeable Baffle Model (1974)

When a high-density turbidity current or liquefied grain flow decelerates rapidly, suspended sand settles at a high rate, trapping 40% to 50% interstitial pore water in a loosely packed grain framework. As sand grains settle into tighter packing (~30โ€“35% porosity), the excess 10โ€“15% pore water is expelled upward by excess pore-fluid pressure (ฮ”Pf):

  1. Filtration Baffling at Primary Laminae: Slight variations in grain size, mica orientation, or fine clay content along sub-horizontal laminae create thin semi-permeable horizontal baffles of lower vertical hydraulic conductivity (Kv).
  2. Underside Clay Accretion and Upward Flexing: As upward-seeping pore water carrying suspended clay platelets encounters a less permeable lamina, water filters through while elutriated clay particles are sieved out and plastered against its base, further lowering permeability.
  3. Marginal Rupture and Pillar Breakthrough: Once the clay-enriched lamina becomes nearly impermeable, trapped water beneath it flows laterally until hydraulic overpressure ruptures the lamina upward at weak points spaced every 5โ€“30 cm, bending the ruptured edges upward into a concave-upward dish and driving a vertical fluidization pillar of clean elutriated sand between adjacent dishes. Because upper levels of the bed transmit the cumulative pore water expelled from the underlying sand column, upward water flux increases toward the top of the bed, breaking upper laminae into narrower, more deeply curved dishes.

Geopetal and Reservoir Engineering Significance

In structural geology and deep-water hydrocarbon exploration, dish structures serve two practical functions. First, because the clay-lined dishes are invariably concave-upward (and the intervening pillars flare upward), dish structures provide an unmistakable way-up (geopetal) criterion in drill cores and overturned fold-and-thrust belts. Second, in deep-water turbidite reservoirs (such as the North Sea Paleogene fans, Gulf of Mexico Wilcox turbidites, and offshore Brazil basins), dense networks of clay-lined dishes reduce vertical-to-horizontal permeability ratios (kv/kh), while vertical sand pillars act as high-permeability bypass conduits across the clay baffles.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do geologists distinguish dish structures from desiccation mudcracks in rock outcrops?

Although both display concave-upward profiles in cross-section, desiccation mudcracks form at the top of cohesive mudstone beds exposed to subaerial drying, display downward-tapering V-shaped wedges filled passively with sand, and occur alongside terrestrial footprints or evaporites. Dish structures occur wholly inside subaqueous sandstone beds (typically deep-marine turbidites), consist of thin (~1 mm) clay-enriched filtration laminae rather than mudstone beds, and are separated by upward-injected fluid-escape sand pillars that bend dish rims upward.

Why do dish structures form only in certain sandstone beds and not in all turbidites?

Dish formation requires two conditions: (1) rapid suspension sedimentation from a high-concentration flow trapping abundant pore water in an underconsolidated sand framework, and (2) faint initial sub-horizontal lamination plus 1โ€“5% fine interstitial clay/mica to act as semi-permeable baffles. Unlaminated, clay-free grain flows expel water uniformly or through vertical pipes without forming dishes, whereas slowly deposited traction sandstones dewater continuously during deposition.

References

  1. Stauffer, P. H. (1967). "Grain-flow deposits and their implications, Santa Ynez Mountains, California." Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, 37(2), 487โ€“508. https://doi.org/10.1306/74D716F9-2B21-11D7-8648000102C1865D
  2. Lowe, D. R., & LoPiccolo, R. D. (1974). "The characteristics and origins of dish and pillar structures." Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, 44(2), 484โ€“501. https://doi.org/10.1306/74D72A68-2B21-11D7-8648000102C1865D
  3. Lowe, D. R. (1975). "Water escape structures in coarse-grained sediments." Sedimentology, 22(2), 157โ€“204. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-3091.1975.tb00290.x
  4. Nichols, R. J., Sparks, R. S. J., & Wilson, C. J. N. (1994). "Experimental studies of the fluidization of layered sediments and the formation of fluid escape structures." Sedimentology, 41(2), 233โ€“253. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-3091.1994.tb01403.x
๐Ÿงฌ Support Open Science
Explore interactive science games on LowKey Games or browse scientific apparel & accessories in the CRV Science Shop.
๐Ÿ’ก Spot an inaccuracy or have primary literature to expand this article?
Submit a citation or revision note using your shared CRV Science / LowKey Games profile ID.
Suggest Revision