← Wiki Index / Geology & Paleontology / Flame Structure
🪨 Geology & Paleontology

Flame Structure

A flame structure is a synsedimentary soft-sediment deformation feature in which cohesive, water-saturated underlying mud is squeezed upward as sharp, overturned tongues between sinking bulbous load casts of an overlying denser sand bed.

Flame structure (also termed a mud flame or load-casted current ripple) is a synsedimentary soft-sediment deformation structure (SSDS) formed along the contact between a lower cohesive mud or silt layer and an overlying rapidly deposited sand bed, in which sharp, curving tongues of the underlying dark mud penetrate upward into the overlying lighter-colored sand like wind-blown tongues of fire. Named and popularized in 1957 by the British geologist Gilbert Kelling and E. K. Walton in their study of lower Paleozoic greywacke turbidite sequences in Scotland ("Load-cast structures: their relationship to upper-surface structures and their mode of origin"), flame structures range from millimeters to several decimeters in height and always develop in tandem with downward-bulging sandy load casts. Because the upward-injected mud tongues point toward the stratigraphic top of the bed and frequently overturn in the downcurrent or downslope direction, flame structures serve field geologists as both a reliable way-up (geopetal) indicator in tectonically inverted strata and a secondary paleocurrent / paleoslope indicator.

Physical Mechanics: Rayleigh–Taylor Instability and Shear Drag

Reverse Density Gradient and Dynamic Liquefaction

Flame structures form shortly after or during the rapid deposition of a dense, water-saturated sand layer atop a hydroplastic, water-rich mud or clay substrate before burial lithification or later diagenetic features such as cone-in-cone structures can develop. Under normal depositional conditions described by the Hjulström curve, newly settled pelagic or hemipelagic clay has a very high initial water content (porosity φ ≈ 70–85%) and consequently a low bulk wet density (ρmud ≈ 1.25 to 1.55 g cm−3). When a high-energy turbidity current, storm tempestite, or delta-front crevasse splay suddenly dumps a decimeter-scale bed of quartz sand (porosity φ ≈ 35–45%, higher bulk wet density ρsand ≈ 1.85 to 2.10 g cm−3) directly atop this uncompacted mud, it creates a gravitationally unstable reverse density gradient (ρupper > ρlower) across the bedding interface.

As long as the sand and mud retain finite yield strength, the flat interface can remain metastably perched. However, as soon as cyclic wave loading, seismic shaking, rapid sedimentation pore-fluid overpressure (which also drives upward water escape in dish structures), or turbulent current shear triggers liquefaction in the sand and thixotropic weakening in the cohesive mud, effective shear strength drops toward zero and the interface deforms as a Rayleigh–Taylor gravitational instability:

  1. Downward Sinking of Sand Lobes (Load Casts): Denser sand lobes sink downward into the underlying mud as broad, bulbous hemispherical load casts (which, if completely detached from the parent sand bed, evolve into isolated ball-and-pillow structures).
  2. Upward Diapiric Injection of Cohesive Mud (Flames): Because the underlying mud has higher dynamic viscosity (μmud > μsand) and inter-particle electrostatic cohesion than the liquefied cohesionless sand, the displaced mud is squeezed upward into the narrow anticlinal cusps between adjacent sinking load casts, tapering into sharp, pointed flame crests while nearby intra-bed laminae fold into convolute lamination.
Soft-Sediment Deformation FeaturePrimary Driving MechanismGeometry of Sand vs. Mud InterfaceWay-Up (Geopetal) & Paleocurrent Utility
Simple Load Casts & Symmetric FlamesPure Rayleigh–Taylor gravitational instability (ρsand > ρmud) after liquefactionBroad, rounded downward sand lobes; sharp, vertical upward mud cuspsUnambiguous way-up indicator: Mud flames point stratigraphically upward
Asymmetric (Overturned) Flame StructuresRayleigh–Taylor loading + unidirectional current shear drag or downslope creepMud flame tips consistently hooked and overturned in one directionWay-up + Paleocurrent/Paleoslope: Flame tips overturn downcurrent / downslope
Ball-and-Pillow StructuresAdvanced Rayleigh–Taylor sinking + complete neck detachment of sand lobesIsolated kidney- or saucer-shaped sand pillows floating inside mud matrixWay-up indicator (flat pillow tops, convex-downward bases)
Dish Structures & PillarsUpward pore-fluid seepage baffled by semi-permeable clay laminaeConcave-upward dark clay dishes (2–50 cm wide) cut by vertical sand pillarsWay-up indicator (dishes always concave-upward)

Viscosity Contrast and Overturning Mechanics

Why Flame Crests Are Sharp While Load Casts Are Rounded

Linear and non-linear fluid dynamic stability analyses by H. Ramberg (1968) and Ph. H. Kuenen demonstrated that the asymmetry between broad, rounded downward sand lobes and narrow, sharp upward mud tongues is controlled by the kinematic viscosity contrast (μmud / μsand) between the two layers. In a Rayleigh–Taylor instability, the medium with the lower effective viscosity (liquefied, cohesionless sand with high pore-water pressure) forms broad, rounded penetratively sinking lobes, whereas the medium with the higher effective viscosity and plastic cohesion (thixotropic clay-rich mud) is pinched into narrow, cuspate diapiric ridges between the expanding sand lobes.

Overturning by Unidirectional Current Shear vs. Seismic Shaking

Whereas pure vertical gravitational loading in a stagnant pond produces symmetric, upright flames, flame structures at the base of Bouma Ta/Tb turbidite beds frequently exhibit consistent unidirectional overturning, with every flame crest drawn out into a wispy hook pointing in the same azimuth:

  • Syndepositional Current Shear Drag: As the overriding turbidity current continues flowing across the freshly deposited, liquefied sand bed while load casting is actively underway, horizontal viscous shear drag (τ0) and unequal pressure loading across current ripples pull the rising mud diapirs forward, overturning the flame tips in the downcurrent direction.
  • Gravitational Downslope Creep: On inclined prodelta or submarine canyon slopes (1°–5°), downslope body forces shear the unlithified sand layer relative to the underlying mud, overturning flames downslope.
  • Seismic Liquefaction ("Seismites"): In lacustrine varves and tidal flats, horizontal ground acceleration during earthquakes (Mw ≥ 5.5) liquefies interbedded silt and clay, generating horizons of complex, multi-directional or chaotically curled flame structures bounded above and below by undeformed horizontal strata.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do geologists use flame structures to tell whether folded rock layers are right-side-up or overturned?

In thrust belts and Alpine-type fold nappes where tectonic deformation has rotated sedimentary beds past the vertical (90°) so the older beds lie physically above the younger beds, geologists examine the basal contacts of sandstone beds against shale. Regardless of post-depositional tectonic folding, the rounded, bulbous sandstone load casts always bulge toward the stratigraphic base (older bed), while the sharp, pointed mudstone flame structures always pinch and taper toward the stratigraphic top (younger bed).

Can flame structures form between two sandstone layers without any mud?

Yes, although mud–sand interfaces are by far the most common, flame structures also develop between a lower fine-grained, muddy or micaceous siltstone/tuff and an upper coarse-grained sandstone or conglomerate (or in volcaniclastic base-surge deposits where dense basaltic lapilli fall onto water-saturated fine volcanic ash), provided that the upper layer has a higher bulk wet density and the lower layer possesses higher effective viscosity during liquefaction.

References

  1. Kelling, G., & Walton, E. K. (1957). "Load-cast structures: Their relationship to upper-surface structures and their mode of origin." Geological Magazine, 94(6), 481–490. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0016756800070175
  2. Lowe, D. R. (1975). "Water escape structures in coarse-grained sediments." Sedimentology, 22(2), 157–204. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-3091.1975.tb00290.x
  3. Owen, G. (1987). "Deformation processes in unconsolidated sands." Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 29(1), 11–24. https://doi.org/10.1144/gsl.sp.1987.029.01.02
  4. Owen, G. (1996). "Experimental soft-sediment deformation: structures formed by the liquefaction of unconsolidated sands and some ancient examples." Sedimentology, 43(2), 279–293. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-3091.1996.d01-5.x
  5. Owen, G. (2003). "Load structures: Gravity-driven sediment mobilization in the shallow subsurface." Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 216(1), 21–34. https://doi.org/10.1144/GSL.SP.2003.216.01.03
🧬 Support Open Science
Explore interactive science games on LowKey Games or browse scientific apparel & accessories in the CRV Science Shop.
💡 Spot an inaccuracy or have primary literature to expand this article?
Submit a citation or revision note using your shared CRV Science / LowKey Games profile ID.
Suggest Revision