Hjulström Curve
The Hjulström Curve is an empirical double-logarithmic hydraulic phase diagram introduced by Filip Hjulström in 1935 that relates clastic sediment grain size to the mean water flow velocity required for particle erosion, transport, and deposition.
Hjulström Curve (also termed the Hjulström–Sundborg diagram) is an empirical double-logarithmic hydraulic phase diagram in sedimentology and fluvial geomorphology that plots mean unidirectional water flow velocity (U, in cm s−1, typically measured 1.0 m above the channel bed) on the vertical axis against clastic particle grain diameter (D, in mm, from clay to boulders) on the horizontal axis to delineate three hydrodynamic regimes: erosion (entrainment), transport (as bedload or suspended load), and deposition (settling). Published in 1935 by the Swedish geographer Filip Hjulström (1902–1982) in his Uppsala University doctoral dissertation on the River Fyris (Studies of the Morphological Activity of Rivers as Illustrated by the River Fyris) and later refined by his student Åke Sundborg (1956), the diagram established a foundational counterintuitive principle of clastic mechanics: fine-grained quartz sand (D ≈ 0.1 to 0.5 mm) is the easiest sediment size to erode, whereas both coarser gravel/cobbles and finer cohesive silt/clay require substantially higher flow velocities for initial entrainment.
Hydrodynamic Regimes and the Two Boundary Curves
The Threshold Entrainment (Erosion) Velocity Curve
The upper boundary curve on the Hjulström diagram—the threshold erosion (entrainment) velocity curve—marks the minimum mean flow velocity required to lift resting sediment grains off the channel bed into motion. Rather than increasing monotonically from clay to boulders, the entrainment curve displays a pronounced U-shaped minimum centered at fine-to-medium sand (D ≈ 0.1–0.5 mm), where incipient motion begins at mean flow velocities of Ucrit ≈ 15 to 20 cm s−1:
- Right Limb (Coarse Sand, Gravel, Cobbles, and Boulders, D > 0.5 mm — Mass and Gravity Controlled): For cohesionless particles larger than 0.5 mm, the submerged gravitational weight of each grain scales with volume (FG ∝ (ρs − ρf)g D3), whereas hydrodynamic drag and lift forces exerted by turbulent flow scale with cross-sectional area (FD ∝ ρf U2 D2). Balancing FD ≈ FG yields Ucrit ∝ D1/2 (Brahms's sixth-power law, where maximum transportable particle mass scales as M ∝ U6). Thus, entraining 10 mm pebbles requires U ≈ 100–150 cm s−1, and entraining 100 mm cobbles requires U > 300–400 cm s−1.
- Left Limb (Cohesive Silt and Clay, D < 0.063 mm — Electrostatic Cohesion and Viscous Sublayer Controlled): As grain diameter drops below 0.063 mm into silt and clay (D < 0.004 mm), two mechanisms cause the required erosion velocity to climb steeply back upward to Ucrit ≈ 100–500 cm s−1 (comparable to coarse gravel). First, phyllosilicate clay platelets (illite, smectite, kaolinite) carry negative surface charges and high specific surface areas, binding particles together through electrostatic van der Waals forces, electrical double-layer attraction, and extracellular polymeric biofilms. Second, fine clay and silt grains lie submerged inside the smooth viscous (laminar) sublayer (δv ≈ 11.6 ν / u*) at the base of the turbulent boundary layer, shielding them from turbulent eddy lift bursts.
| Wentworth Grain Size Class | Particle Diameter (D, mm) | Threshold Erosion Velocity Uerode (cm s−1) | Threshold Deposition Velocity Udep (cm s−1) | Dominant Physical Control on Entrainment & Settling |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Consolidated Clay | < 0.004 mm | 150–500 cm s−1 | < 0.01–0.1 cm s−1 | Electrostatic van der Waals cohesion + viscous sublayer shielding; Stokes settling |
| Cohesive Silt | 0.004–0.063 mm | 30–150 cm s−1 | 0.1–0.8 cm s−1 | Moderate inter-particle cohesion + smooth boundary physics |
| Fine–Medium Quartz Sand | 0.1–0.5 mm | 15–20 cm s−1 (Global Minimum) | 1.0–4.0 cm s−1 | Cohesionless grains protruding into turbulent shear; minimum threshold |
| Coarse Sand to Granules | 0.5–4.0 mm | 20–60 cm s−1 | 4.0–30 cm s−1 | Submerged gravitational mass inertia (FG ∝ D3); transitional settling |
| Pebbles & Cobbles (Gravel) | 4.0–256 mm | 60–400+ cm s−1 | 30–250+ cm s−1 | Turbulent impact settling (ws ∝ D1/2); narrow transport gap |
The Threshold Deposition (Settling) Velocity Curve and the Transport Gap
The lower boundary curve on the Hjulström diagram—the threshold deposition (fall) velocity curve—marks the velocity below which suspended or saltating particles settle back onto the bed. Unlike the U-shaped erosion curve, the deposition curve increases monotonically with grain diameter D across the spectrum because once cohesive clay flocs and silt grains have been dispersed into the water column, bed cohesion no longer resists gravity:
- Fine Particles (D < 0.1 mm — Stokes' Law Regime, Rep < 1): Laminar viscous drag dominates over inertial drag, so terminal settling velocity scales with the square of grain diameter: ws = (ρs − ρf)g D2 / (18 μ). Consequently, dispersed clay particles (< 0.004 mm) remain in suspension even at near-zero flow velocities (U < 0.01 cm s−1), settling only in quiescent lake basins, deep abyssal plains, or by estuarine salt flocculation alongside fine particulate allochthonous and autochthonous carbon.
- Coarse Particles (D > 2 mm — Turbulent Impact Law Regime, Rep > 1,000): Form drag dominates, and settling velocity scales with the square root of diameter: ws ∝ [(ρs − ρf)g D / ρf]1/2. For gravel and cobbles, the deposition curve lies just slightly below the erosion curve, meaning coarse bedload is deposited rapidly once flow decelerates below the entrainment threshold.
Comparison with the Shields Diagram and Turbidite Facies
While the Hjulström curve remains a staple of fluvial geomorphology and paleocurrent reconstruction because mean flow velocity U is intuitive to interpret in rivers and submarine canyons, hydraulic engineers noted in 1936 (Albert Shields) that mean velocity at 1 m depth depends on total flow depth (h), fluid kinematic viscosity (ν), and particle density (ρs). The Shields diagram replaces dimensional velocity U with the dimensionless Shields parameter (dimensionless boundary shear stress, θc = τ0 / [(ρs − ρf)g D]) plotted against the boundary Reynolds number (Re = u D / ν).
In deep-marine and lacustrine basin analysis, the Hjulström transport gap between erosion and deposition explains the vertical sequence of sedimentary structures in a waning turbidite (the Bouma sequence Ta–e) and associated soft-sediment deformation structures: when a high-velocity sandy turbidity current decelerates rapidly over a cohesive mud substrate, it cannot easily erode the cohesive pelagic clay bed (generating basal load casts and flame structures rather than complete mud dispersal), while rapid suspension fallout of fine-to-medium sand expels pore water upward to form dish structures before late-stage burial diagenesis in the underlying organic-rich mudstones precipitates cone-in-cone structures.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why can a muddy river stay turbid even when its flow slows to a crawl, yet require a flood to erode its clay banks?
This behavior reflects the wide Hjulström transport field at fine grain sizes (D < 0.004 mm). Eroding consolidated clay from a riverbank requires flood velocities of 150 to 500 cm s−1 to overcome inter-platelet electrostatic van der Waals attraction and penetrate the viscous boundary sublayer. Once detached into suspended platelets, however, clay particles obey Stokes' law (ws ∝ D2) with settling velocities below 0.001 cm s−1, allowing gentle turbulence to keep them suspended.
Why is Aeolian and subaqueous sand on beaches and dunes so well sorted around 0.15 to 0.35 mm?
Fine-to-medium quartz sand (0.15–0.35 mm) occupies the global minimum of the Hjulström entrainment curve (Ucrit ≈ 15–18 cm s−1). Moderate currents, wave swash, and winds selectively entrain 0.2 mm sand grains while leaving coarser gravel (too heavy to lift) and cohesive mud layers (bound by cohesion) behind, and then deposit that sand once current velocity drops below ~2–3 cm s−1.
References
- Hjulström, F. (1935). "Studies of the morphological activity of rivers as illustrated by the River Fyris." Bulletin of the Geological Institution of the University of Uppsala, 25, 221–527. https://uu.diva-portal.org/smash/record.jsf?pid=diva2:1273943
- Sundborg, Å. (1956). "The River Klarälven: A study of fluvial processes." Geografiska Annaler, 38(2–3), 125–316. https://doi.org/10.1080/20014422.1956.11880887
- Shields, A. (1936). Anwendung der Ähnlichkeitsmechanik und der Turbulenzforschung auf die Geschiebebewegung. Mitteilungen der Preußischen Versuchsanstalt für Wasserbau und Schiffbau, 26, 1–26. https://resolver.tudelft.nl/uuid:61a19716-a994-4942-9906-f680eb9952d6
- Miller, M. C., McCave, I. N., & Komar, P. D. (1977). "Threshold of sediment motion under unidirectional currents." Sedimentology, 24(4), 507–527. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-3091.1977.tb00136.x